Gutting female athletics: An “Equality Act” tragedy
By Robert G. Marshall ( bio - articles - email ) | Mar 12, 2021
“Transgender discrimination” is the “Civil Rights issue of our time,” according to President Biden. “Equality” in sports for President Biden and Democrat House Speaker Nancy Pelosi means allowing a 260 pound male high school football lineman to ram any 118 pound Sally Smith flat on her back on the Soccer field. President Biden and Speaker Pelosi are pushing HR 5, the so-called Equality Act, which will make “transgender females” (guys who “identify” as female) play on previously female-only sports teams.
When the Equality Act was debated in the House Judiciary Committee in 2019, Congressman Steube (R-FL) proposed an amendment “that nothing in the Act…may be construed to require a biological female to face competition from a biological male in any sporting event.” Steube’s amendment failed 10 yeas to 22 nays. All Democrats voted no, and all Republicans voted yes.
In late February, 2021, Congressman Steube again proposed his amendment, “which bans recipients of Federal funds from permitting biological males from competing with biological women or girls.” He lost 7-4 in the Rules Committee, and was not allowed to offer his amendment on the floor of the House of Representatives when HR 5 was considered this year.
Bottom line: The Equality Act means that guys “identifying” as “Transwomen” will not only dominate women in sports, they will also shower and use the same locker room as the girls.
At the 2019 hearing, Law Professor Doriane Coleman, Villanova track scholarship recipient in 1978, noted the benefits of the present system for biological women:
- “Since the passage of Title IX . . . , female participation in sport has increased more than 900%.”
- Tens of thousands of girls and women are now eligible for college scholarships, ensuring educational opportunities that for many wouldn’t be realistic otherwise.
- “Girls who play sports stay in school longer, suffer fewer health problems, enter the labor force at higher rates, and are more likely to land better jobs. They are also more likely to lead.”
The Equality Act will erase all sports and other benefits for women.
Professor Coleman also stated that men and women are not equal in athletic abilities because of Nature. She pointed to lifetime best records of female Olympic Champions in the 400 meters, including Team USA’s Sanya Richards-Ross and Allyson Felix. The absolute best sports-titled women would automatically lose to thousands of boys and men, including thousands of men in the second tier level.
In 2019, eighteen-time Tennis Grand Slam winner Martina Navratilova, an acknowledged lesbian, took issue with Equality Act treatment of biological female athletes:
Sport…is a public space where the relevance of sex is undeniable.… The evidence is unequivocal that starting in puberty, in every sport except sailing, shooting and riding, there will always be significant numbers of boys and men who would beat the best girls and women in head-to-head competition. Claims to the contrary are simply a denial of science.
A recent Politico national sample poll of 1900 registered voters (March 6-8, 2021) asked respondents if they supported Mississippi “banning transgender athletes from participating on women’s sports teams at the state’s high schools and universities.” Among all registered voters, 53% supported the Mississippi ban, 32% opposed, and 16% had no opinion.
Yet, at present, all but one Democrat in Congress supported coercing women to compete against men in all sports, while all but four Republicans opposed it.
Senator Tuberville (R-AL), a former high school boys’ football coach and a girls’ basketball coach, offered an amendment to HR 1319 (the Covid Relief Act) to ban using federal money for biological males competing in female athletics. The amendment lost 50 nays to 49 yeas with one not voting.
President Biden’s then nominee, now Secretary of Education, supports making girls compete against guys in sports. This was made clear in questioning of Michael Cardona on February 3, 2021 by Senator Rand Paul (R-KY).
Sen. Rand Paul: What do you think about boys in girls’ track meets like in Connecticut?
Michael Cordona: I think it is important for all students including those that are transgender, and they’re afforded all of the opportunities they have....
Sen. Paul: Does it bother you that like the top 20% of boys running in track beat all of the girls in the state and it would completely destroy girls athletics…if they don’t make the finals they don’t get college scholarships…. Do you think it is fair?
Cordona: I think it is appropriate…schools should engage students in extracurricular activities, even if they’re transgender.…
Sen. Paul: You’re going to run the Department of Education and you have no problem with it…. What planet are you from? To think that boys competing with girls at a track meet, that that would be fair, that concerns me…the fact that you’re answering the question saying it’s okay without saying it is okay is a problem.…
The House-passed version of the Equality Act is now before the U. S. Senate. Please contact your US Senator and urge them to vote no on the Equality Act. And ask if they think it is fair to make girls compete against boys in sports competitions.
Point out that males have roughly 40% more muscle mass and 40% less body fat. By nature, boys are taller, faster and stronger than girls and can metabolize more oxygen than girls. Ask if they care that women will lose Title IX benefits including sports scholarships which provide educational opportunities and economic advancement including for minority women.
CatholicCulture.org is not a political action organization but, in furtherance of its Catholic mission, authorizes free distribution of this analysis of political initiatives which violate a Catholic understanding of the human person. For those unfamiliar with how to contact their Senators, we also provide the following public links:
- How did your Senator vote on the Tuberville ban on boys competing against girls in sports?
- Who is my US Senator?
Previous in series: Cancel culture comes to Catholics and all Christians
Next in series: Joe Biden, Nancy Pelosi seek to close Catholic-Christian adoption agencies
All comments are moderated. To lighten our editing burden, only current donors are allowed to Sound Off. If you are a current donor, log in to see the comment form; otherwise please support our work, and Sound Off!
Posted by: [email protected] -
Mar. 13, 2021 1:44 PM ET USA
If women and parents of young girls have any common sense they will refuse to participate in any sport that has transgender males. Hopefully those running these programs will get the message. This will take courage on everyone's part.