Make your gift today!
Help keep Catholics around the world educated and informed.
Already donated? Log in to stop seeing these donation pop-ups.
Why Catholics Should Take Nick Fuentes Seriously
By Peter Wolfgang ( bio - articles - email ) | Nov 21, 2026
A quick scan of the past weeks’ Catholic commentary on several of my favorite websites shows no reaction to Catholic white nationalist Nick Fuentes’ speech at the recent New Christian Right (NXR) After MAGA Conference in Texas. This strikes me as a mistake. Fuentes is not some mere internet clown to be ignored. Taking him seriously does not mean taking his side. But his speech was brilliant, speaking truly and clearly about the sorry state of the American Right while carefully downplaying the ethnic hatred in which he usually traffics. The speech, and the man behind it, ought to be engaged.
Our Protestant friends, on the other hand, are taking the NXR phenomenon with utmost seriousness. That makes sense since, as Mark Tooley writes, “Much of self-identified Christian Nationalism has been intellectual Calvinism focused on 16th and 17th century political theology.” In other words, it’s their baby. Texas minister Joel Webbon appears to be to NXR what Yoram Hazony is to National Conservatism: its originator, organizer and chief theorist. You can read Mark Tooley’s response here, Andrew T. Walker here, and John Ehrett here.
I don’t take the NXR as seriously for reasons like those articulated by Rod Dreher about Christian Nationalism overall (of which NXR is just one variety). That is, absent some mass conversion to militant Calvinism (which seems unlikely), this thing isn’t going anywhere. As Dreher writes more broadly, those “who wish to use the power of an activist government to impose Christian values on the country, will either never come to power, or if they do, will fail. The precondition of a strong Christian government is a majority Christian polity. We do not have that.”
We certainly don’t have it for Webbon-style Calvinism. It may be that Webbon knows this too and that this is why he invited others outside of his theological milieu to speak at NXR. If so, he hit paydirt with Fuentes, who gave the only speech worth watching. I am with Dreher in his belief that Fuentes’ reach among the under-30 crowd is way bigger than people realize. It’s not hard to see why. Fuentes’ appearance on Tucker Carlson got all the attention last year but it was a later appearance on Piers Morgan that was the more interesting interview.
Unlike Tucker, Piers went at Fuentes hard—and got his head handed to him. I don’t think Piers knew what hit him. And Fuentes? He was riffing about Karl Popper’s The Open Society as if he were ghost-writing a Rusty Reno column for First Things. And at one point in his NXR speech, Fuentes suddenly broke from his political topics to emphasize the need for a Christ-centered “interior life,” as if he had just been reading St. Josemaría Escrivá. There is a lot more going on inside his head than just being some little wise guy who wants to freak out the squares.
In his NXR speech, Fuentes distinguished between Trumpism and Trump himself, arguing that the latter had betrayed the former. He’s not wrong. In 2016 we were told there would be no more forever wars, that the swamp would be drained, and that our economic policy would be America First. Governing is always tougher than campaigning and Trump did make real progress. But between the Iran War, his tone-deafness on affordability, his self-dealing, and his downgrading of the pro-life cause, much of the momentum of his historic re-election seems to have been wasted. Fuentes smells an opportunity. And, again, he’s not wrong. The young want some higher goal than just voting for the lesser of two evils. And yes, as Fuentes says, TPUSA’s meaningless “ethical monotheism” isn’t it. They want Jesus Christ.
The problem is what Fuentes didn’t say (or downplayed) in his speech. The ethnic centrality of his vision—the racism, the antisemitism—are a feature, not a bug, of Groyperism. It is precisely as a Catholic that I recoil at them. I get what it is the kids are reacting against. The Left has stacked the deck such that young white men feel they are navigating a world arrayed against them. Older conservatives like me, who believe in the ideal of a colorblind society, seem not to understand the problem or to have acquiesced in it.
But indulging in political fantasy is not going to solve any of it. And marching to this program under the cry made famous in this hemisphere by the Mexican Cristeros—“Christ is King”—is to fundamentally misunderstand Christ’s kingship, which is not of this world. No Christian movement, by definition, would make race its central principle. Nor will the Catholic Church support antisemitism, conspiracy theorizing about Jewish power, or the blasphemous misuse of Christ’s name in the service of Jew-hatred.
Every movement, every political project, must be judged by whether it conforms to Christ. And as Catholics ought to know better than anyone, we don’t get to define Christianity for ourselves. Christ is King. Fuentes is not.
Next post
All comments are moderated. To lighten our editing burden, only current donors are allowed to Sound Off. If you are a current donor, log in to see the comment form; otherwise please support our work, and Sound Off!



