How do we know there is a true religion—and recognize it?
By Catholic Culture ( articles - email ) | Nov 20, 2026
In my recent article on ecumenism, I stressed that ecumenism has only a marginal and purely human value if it does not go beyond friendly understanding to fulfill God’s purpose. As St. Paul expressed that purpose, “God desires all men to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth” (1 Tim 2:4). And as Christ Himself said to Peter: “Simon, Simon, behold, Satan demanded to have you, that he might sift you like wheat, but I have prayed for you that your faith may not fail; and when you have turned again, strengthen your brethren” (Lk 22:31-2).
Yet one of the great problems which plagues religious belief throughout history and throughout the world today is the twin problem of credulity and incredulity. It seems that most people everywhere believe whatever is most convenient, or even most advantageous. And they disbelieve whatever most others disbelieve, or whatever, so to speak, cramps their style. Thus in every corner of the globe, most people profess to believe whatever is expected of them by the world, that is, whatever is approved as true by the dominant culture in which they find themselves.
Indeed, the human person is remarkably prone to go along to get along, though it is also true that once people have more or less reflexively adopted a certain worldview, they have an in-built tendency to reinforce within themselves the presumption that what they believe must be true. After all, if we entertain the notion that the ideas and values on which we habitually act are false…well, that demands an energy from us that we frequently do not wish to expend, and a determination which we would generally prefer to avoid. In fact, it is not too much to say that, when faced with the personal inconveniences imposed by the larger social order (and thus the courage it typically takes to think outside the box), we humans typically prefer to avoid rather than to confront.
For these reasons, the typical man or woman spends the bulk of his or her life avoiding what we might call ultimate reality—or perhaps I should simply call it avoiding inconvenience. I certainly do this at times; I’ll bet you do too. But it is far better not to sweat the small stuff than the big stuff. And it should not be too hard to realize, if we can take a moment for some slow honesty, that our ultimate destiny as human persons is…the big stuff.
Where to look?
When it comes to religious belief, it is not too much to say that we have to know where to look. There are a great many claims on offer, but if the truth about God and our relationship with God were personally convenient, then the world would not be in such perpetual confusion about it. Indeed, this may actually be a help in the long run, for if the truth about God and our relationship with God were as plain as the nose on our faces (and, of course, if people were not perpetually confused even about obvious things), then most of us would accept it out of necessity rather than out of love. Therefore, one of the things we must wrestle with is the question of why, if God exists, He does not make His presence more obvious. Why doesn’t He simply confront us with His Divine Majesty?
One reason, perhaps, is that there is no virtue, and so no spiritual growth, and indeed no love at all, in acclaiming what we are forced to acclaim. When faced with the God question, we are inescapably faced with the question of why it is so difficult for us to perceive God’s reality and God’s presence. Indeed, this problem is so significant that it is one of the questions we would expect not only logic but true religion to answer. And, while that is not the topic of this particular article, I might pause to mention that the blindness created by temptation and sin—and even the Original Sin—is a more important and even fruitful part of true religion that we might initially imagine.
Still, I think that first we must consider not the specifics of the answer but the the general shape an answer must have in order to be both plausible and probable. In Catholic apologetics, this is the general shape which a particular form of religion simply must possess if it is to be considered the real and true form. After all, it is no great advance to be convinced that there must be a God (since that is evident even to any unselfish and disinterested human logic). We have but to consider things like first causes, prime movers, and material contingency with an open mind. But while the conviction that God exists is rational (while the conviction that there is no God is irrational), there is nothing compellingly personal in that, and so it doesn’t take us very far.
Going farther
However, it takes us somewhat further to recognize that if there is a Creator who went “to all the trouble” to create everything, including us, then it seems overwhelmingly likely that He cares about us, wants us to know Him, and indeed has some plan for us. And it is just here that we come up against an overwhelming likelihood—the likelihood without which nothing makes any sense at all—namely, that if God made us with intellect and will (both of which we clearly possess) then he must have some plan for us concerning the use of these gifts. And if God has a plan, then He must certainly have a way of revealing that plan.
Now, we may face unusual circumstances which restrict our ability to reach this conclusion. Or we may just be afflicted with a self-absorbing narcissism. But it ought to be precisely this overwhelming likelihood that causes us to look for information about our purpose that can only have come from God—that is, we ought to be looking for a revelation. Of course, we could argue that nature itself is a kind of revelation (and this is what everyone who is not in a sort of selfish denial almost inescapably recognizes), but nature does not give us many specific instructions about Who this Creator God is, or what he expects of us, or how we might thank Him and even get to know Him. No, for that we need some sort of specific Revelation.
And it is precisely because we so badly need this specific Revelation that we ought to expect that a God who wishes to be known by His rational creatures would provide it. Therefore, not only do we look for a revelation (both in nature and in more direct and rational sorts of communication), but we begin to think about what sort of characteristics an alleged revelation (God revealing Himself) would have to have in order to be both suitable to the purpose and, above all, credible. Then, if we have any sense at all, we must almost immediately conclude that any sort of deliberate Divine Revelation ought to carry with it certain identifying signs, signs which distinguish it from all other kinds of communication.
So let us consider:
- First, the Revelation must be attested by signs that only God can produce. It cannot just be another human artifact or theory. Therefore, we would logically expect any Divine Revelation to be attended by both clear miracles and clear foreknowledge (or what we typically call prophecy).
- Second, the Revelation, insofar as it is entrusted to men, must have within it an authority principle, that is, a means of guaranteeing its true transmission through all the vagaries of human history and human thought.
- Third, the authoritative explication of this Revelation, both at any given time and throughout our history, must display a remarkable consistency, so that (as Newman put it), all teachings protected by this authority principle involve only those developments in our understanding that corroborate and confirm the original Revelation, rather than involving any sort of substantive change or contradiction.
These points are so obvious that I need not say anything more about them here. But if we are serious about what we might call the quest for God (and certainly we should be very serious about so basic and so rational a human impulse, without which nothing makes any sense at all), then we will immediately dismiss all explanations that lack these essential criteria. It goes without saying, after all, that many wayward men and women will make all kinds of claims for their own understanding of reality. But we must look for the one explanation that passes each of these basic tests—and the one authority which guarantees each of these basic truths.
This is hardly rocket science; but it does, in our own human understanding, mean leaving the ways of the world behind.
Next post
All comments are moderated. To lighten our editing burden, only current donors are allowed to Sound Off. If you are a current donor, log in to see the comment form; otherwise please support our work, and Sound Off!



