Leo and Attila

By Thomas V. Mirus ( bio - articles - email ) | Nov 16, 2026 | In Lives of the Popes

Previous installment

In the final years of Pope St. Leo the Great, he would continue to deal with the fallout of the Council of Chalcedon, especially turbulence in Egypt caused by seditious monophysites. And famously, he would confront Attila the Hun face to face.

But first, a quick digression on an aspect of Leo’s reign which didn’t fit in any of the earlier installments. Readers will recall that there could be serious controversies within the early Church over reckoning the correct date of Easter. This issue came up again in Leo’s time, and could have resulted in even more tension between Rome and the East, had it been dealt with by another pope. But St. Leo showed his humility and diplomacy in handling this matter.

The emperors since Constantine had been concerned to establish a common date throughout the empire, but some differences still existed in Leo’s time, especially between Rome and Alexandria. Specifically, Rome’s calculation of the range of dates in which Easter could occur was somewhat different from Alexandria’s. However, the Council of Nicaea had given Alexandria the right to calculate the date of Easter and to notify Rome of the date annually—this because of Alexandria’s superior tradition of mathematics.

When a year arrived in which Alexandria’s date for Easter fell outside the limits allowed by Rome, Leo deferred to the Alexandrian practice. When a discrepancy came up again some years later, Leo thought that the Alexandrians must be using faulty calculations, and he made inquiries about their reason for the divergence. But ultimately, even though he thought Rome’s calculations were better, Leo again decided to follow the Alexandrian date, both for the sake of the unity of the Church and to follow the canon of Nicaea.

Thus, despite other Western bishops resenting this concession, St. Leo averted what could have been a major cause of division, even of schism, on top of everything else that was going on. He did not need Rome’s preference to prevail in everything. And it’s just as well that he conceded the point, because the Alexandrians were in fact just doing better math than the Romans.

The Egyptian controversy

And now back to the aftermath of Chalcedon. It should be mentioned that throughout his dealings with the East, Leo relied for information on his friend and frequent advisor, Bishop Julian of Cios. Leo made Julian his legate in the East, to report on and intervene in affairs not only in Constantinople, but also in Palestine and Egypt, where the Tome was being rejected by followers of Eutyches.

Leo was quite concerned about the monophysite monks in Jerusalem, and made efforts to clear up any possible theological miscommunications and reconcile them to the Church, even after they had committed violence against priests and bishops.

As for Egypt, the exiled Bishop Dioscorus died in late 454. But even after he was gone, most Egyptian Christians refused to accept the Definition of Chalcedon. The orthodox Catholic bishop of Alexandria, Proterius, was only kept in office by the presence of imperial troops.

So when Emperor Marcian died in early 455, the Egyptians saw their chance. A mob seized control of the cathedral, and a virulent anti-Chalcedonian named Timothy was consecrated bishop by two bishops who themselves had been excommunicated. Soon after, on the vigil of Easter, the mob murdered the real bishop, Proterius, in the baptistery of another church. His body was dragged through the city and publicly burned.

Both the pro—and the anti-Chalcedonians quickly made appeals to the new Emperor Leo, as well as to St. Anatolius of Constantinople. It took some time for Pope Leo to be fully informed of events in Alexandria, and he was likely anxious to learn what the new emperor’s policy would be, since Emperor Leo had not yet responded to the pope’s letters urging him to suppress heresy. He directed Julian, his legate in the East, to do everything he could to restore orthodoxy in Alexandria, in particular by securing the election of a Catholic bishop.

St. Leo was also troubled by reports that the monophysites were advocating for a new council to revise Chalcedon. Even at Constantinople, the monophysite cause was once again making headway. The pope quickly sent a whole batch of letters to various bishops, to Emperor Leo, and to St. Anatolius, urging against any such plan, and insisting on the finality of the Definition and the Tome. But the emperor wrote that the only way to restore order was to hold another council.

Pope Leo was not consoled by Emperor Leo’s assurance that the only purpose of such a council would be to reaffirm the Nicene faith, given that this really amounted to saying that Chalcedon and the Tome had not been sufficient. The situation was frighteningly similar to that which had led up to the Robber Council in 449. There was even a threat that Alexandria might convince Constantinople to abandon the Chalcedonian Definition, in exchange for Constantinople being allowed to keep the primacy claimed in Canon 28.

So the pope wrote back to the emperor insisting that another council would only increase divisions, not alleviate them. He invoked the full authority of Peter against those who wanted to undermine what had been defined. He told the emperor that the purpose of his authority was to protect the Church, not only to keep civil order. He ought to punish the usurpers and patricides at Alexandria and restore the faith there, as well as banishing heterodox clergy from the city of Constantinople. The Anglican biographer of St. Leo, Trevor Jalland, said of this letter:

Not only does it show that at this time the Roman see was the only substantial bulwark of the Chalcedonian decrees, but it reveals the present holder of that see as a man of imperious will who does not fear to remind the Sovereign of his duty and even to dictate to him an appropriate course of action. When elsewhere all was change, transition and uncertainty the Roman Pontiff stands out as one who is conscious of a supreme vocation to be the arbiter of the world’s spiritual destiny and who is determined to allow nothing to hinder him in the fulfilment of his responsibility.

But the emperor persisted, asking St. Leo to send legates to take part in a council to be held at Constantinople. Leo agreed to send them, but only for the purpose of stating the rule of faith, not of debating it with opponents. To question the Definition was to offend against God and against Nicaea. Those who did not agree with Chalcedon should not even be permitted to participate in discussion about it.

But then the emperor changed his mind. Instead of summoning bishops to a council, he sent a questionnaire to the various provinces with two questions: “Ought the council of Chalcedon to be upheld?” and “Ought Timothy to be recognized as bishop of Alexandria?” And, thankfully, only one province responded against Chalcedon, while all of them opposed Timothy.

The pope was not informed of this right away, so he still sent legates to Constantinople with two letters to the Emperor. In the first, in addition to reiterating his ban on debate about the Definition and urging a new bishop for Alexandria, he generally excommunicated anyone who engaged in controversy against the Definition. Timothy and the others guilty of the murder of Proterius he said to be beyond human absolution, though if they would stop persecuting the Church, Catholics might pray for God Himself to forgive them. The second letter was an explanation of the teaching of Chalcedon, with a collection of supporting texts from the Church Fathers.

On the basis of Pope Leo’s statement that Timothy might at least have the prayers of Catholics if he ceased attacking the Church, Emperor Leo sent an offer of peace to Timothy. This last chance being haughtily refused, the emperor commanded that Timothy be arrested and brought to the capital. Even now refusing to change his ways, Timothy was banished just as Dioscorus had been. And finally, Emperor Leo nominated a new bishop for Alexandria, a Catholic also named Timothy. If only that had been the end of heresy and schism in Egypt!

The pope and the barbarians

In the year 452, Attila the Hun entered northern Italy and started heading south. The Western Emperor, Valentinian, together with the Senate, decided to forestall the Hun’s arrival at the gates of Rome by sending an embassy up north to make peace. The chosen ambassadors were two leading senators and the bishop of Rome.

This was not the first time a pope had left Rome on a diplomatic mission to avert the destruction of the city by barbarians. St. Innocent I had made such an attempt with regard to Alaric and the Goths, but his mission had failed. Whereas St. Leo’s mission succeeded so well, and with so little explanation, that it has attained legendary status.

We really have no idea what was said or what happened at that meeting at Lake Garda to convince Attila to withdraw from Italy. We don’t know whether sole credit belongs to St. Leo or whether the senators may have contributed to the mission’s success. The legend has forgotten the senators, leaving us with the image of the elderly pontiff alone confronting the great warlord. It has given us paintings and sculptures, such as the large marble relief over St. Leo’s tomb in St. Peter’s Basilica, depicting Leo gesturing up at the figures of Sts. Peter and Paul brandishing swords in the sky as Attila the Hun cringes in fear. The first mention of a supernatural intervention, in the form of a mysterious visitor, comes in a history written by Paul the Deacon in the mid-eighth century. Later this was interpreted to be St. Peter, and when Raphael painted the scene he added in St. Paul for good measure.

The various barbarian invaders of Italy tended to have a religious sensibility, even though they were not Catholics and in Attila’s case, not even Christians. We can assume that Attila was impressed by the figure of St. Leo, which combined the spiritual authority of his office with personal sanctity as well as a mastery of diplomatic art. And we can be certain that the mission’s success was the fruit of prayer. Among other possible factors, the Greek historian Priscus, who had actually had dinner with Attila a few years before his entrance into Italy, said that the Hun had just received bad news from his own kingdom, and that his advisors cautioned him that the last man to capture Rome, Alaric, had died soon after (it has even been speculated that a Roman bribe induced them to say this).

But all we truly know is that after this meeting, Attila left Italy and took his Huns with him.

Three years later, Leo would have to do the same thing over again under direr circumstances. This time, he could not save Rome from being captured by Gaiseric and his Vandals. This all came about because of the worthless new Emperor Petronius, a senator who had Valentinian assassinated and bribed his way to the throne. Petronius then forced Valentinian’s daughter, who had been engaged to the son of Gaiseric, to marry his own son instead. Having thus provoked a Vandal invasion, Petronius decided to give up the eternal city without a fight, and as he tried to flee he was killed by the Roman people he had served so ill.

This time, St. Leo really was alone in confronting the barbarian conqueror. The day before the Vandals entered Rome, Leo went out and convinced Gaiseric to moderate his sack of the city, at least not to burn buildings or massacre and torture civilians. He seems even to have convinced them not to plunder the major basilicas, though the lesser churches were robbed. Probably it helped that the Vandals were Christians, albeit Arian heretics. Still, over the course of two weeks, the city was despoiled of many treasures, thousands of Roman nobles including the Empress and her daughter were taken captive, and many buildings were damaged (hence the word “vandalism”).

After this disaster, six years remained to Leo’s reign, during which time the Western imperial throne continued to be degraded by manipulation and coups. Starting in 457, the Roman Gothic general Ricimer would rule for seventeen years through four successive puppet emperors, the first three of whom he would kill when they no longer served his purposes. It was the beginning of the end for the Roman Empire in the West. But we have no information about St. Leo’s involvement with the Western emperors after Valentinian, or about his governance of the Roman see in these years. Much of his late correspondence is with the East.

Pope St. Leo the Great met his eternal reward on November 10, 461. His relics were interred in the entrance to the sacristy of the Constantinian basilica of St. Peter, and later moved into the church proper. Finally, when Constantine’s basilica was demolished to make way for the present St. Peter’s, St. Leo’s remains were placed under the altar of the southwestern chapel, where they can be venerated today.

Thomas V. Mirus is President of Trinity Communications and Editor-in-Chief for CatholicCulture.org, hosts both the Catholic Culture Podcast and Lives of the Popes, and co-hosts Criteria: The Catholic Film Podcast. See full bio.

Read more

Next post

Sound Off! CatholicCulture.org supporters weigh in.

All comments are moderated. To lighten our editing burden, only current donors are allowed to Sound Off. If you are a current donor, log in to see the comment form; otherwise please support our work, and Sound Off!

There are no comments yet for this item.