The WYSIWYG Pontiff
By Phil Lawler ( bio - articles - email ) | Nov 17, 2026
For more than 17 months now, Catholic journalists have been speculating about what sort of policy changes Pope Leo XIV will introduce. Will he be in effect “Francis II,” continuing an era of changes at the Vatican? Or will he reject the novelties? Or strike out in his own new chosen directions?
When the newly elected Pope Leo did not conform to any of those models—when his early public statements showed sympathy first for progressives, then for traditionalists—the Vatican-watchers assumed that he was biding his time. He was inscrutable; he was the Pope with the Mona Lisa smile. But sooner or later he would show his hand.
By now I propose that it’s time to end the speculation, and recognize that Pope Leo is not simply playing a part. His carefully balanced statements are not intended to mask his intentions; they are his intentions. With this Pontiff, what you see is what you get.
Pope Leo took office at a time of severe, even dangerous, division within the universal Church. He rarely makes a public statement without emphasizing the need for unity, implicitly reminding listeners that the role of the Sovereign Pontiff is to be a focus of unity, not an instigator of change. Look to his exchange with reporters, on his flight back to Rome after his visit to South America, to see the clear pattern of his intentions.
Even the in-flight press conference was itself, in a way, a sign of continuity. Just a few days earlier, when the Pope did not answer reporters’ questions on the flight from Rome, journalists had concluded that he was breaking with the “tradition” set by the last few Popes. Not so; he answered questions patiently and fully. If none of his answers caused the sort of sensational headlines that Pope Francis regularly produced, that too is indicative of the new Pope’s style.
Not that Pope Leo calls attention to the difference. He said that he has no plans to overturn Traditionis Custodes, “for the unity of the Church.” As he has shown on multiple occasions, he is loath to renounce decisions made by Pope Francis. On the other hand he quickly followed up by mentioning—twice—that there are “possibilities of dispensation” from Traditionis Custodes, presumably also for the unity of the Church.
Questioned about the possibility of admitting married men to the priesthood, he said, “The door is not closed.” But then he added that changing the longstanding discipline of the Roman Church “can cause division.” He then added—in case anyone missed the central message—that “one of my priorities is first to promote unity and communion among us as members of the Church.”
Even in his answers to questions about political issues—issues that were obviously discussed during his stay in Argentina, and issues that arose because he chose to cast a vote in the US elections—Pope Leo spoke first about the need to avoid polarization.
Actually the most revealing answer that the Pontiff gave during that airplane interview may have been a response to a question about his priorities: “I don’t feel like I need to adjust them, thank you, but things will continue as we’ve been doing, basically.”
You heard what the Pope said. Church unity is his first priority. He doesn’t plan to change his priorities. What you see is what you get.
Among the many unwelcome changes that Pope Francis brought to the Vatican was the new idea that each Pope would promote his own personal agenda for change. To be sure, every Pontiff has his own priorities, his own personal style of governing the Church. A new pontificate always brings subtle changes, most of them interesting only to the journalists who specialize in Vatican affairs. But until Pope Francis, no modern Pontiff would unabashedly break with important decisions made by his predecessors.
Pope John XXIII, with his characteristic humor, once remarked that he had to be the Pope for the man with his foot on the gas pedal, and also the Pope for the man with his foot on the brake. Pope Leo has brought the same attitude back to Peter’s Throne. Not surprisingly, while he has never rejected the policies set by Pope Francis, he has on several occasions tapped the brake.
So stop waiting to see where Pope Leo is headed. We know what he plans. If he fails to fuel the sort of controversy that keeps commentators busy, that is not an accident; he wants to heal divisions, not aggravate them.
One more thing: Catholics who disapprove of Pope Leo’s determination to stay in the middle of the road—who wish that he would strike out in one direction or the other—may have to live with their frustration for a long time. He is still only 71, and his quick recovery from cancer surgery, so evident in his performance in South America, highlights his robust health. As he told reporters on the plane, “stamina is one of the gifts the Lord has given me.”
Next post
All comments are moderated. To lighten our editing burden, only current donors are allowed to Sound Off. If you are a current donor, log in to see the comment form; otherwise please support our work, and Sound Off!



