The Good Thief: My Week on Death Row with Michael Ross
By Jeremiah Rufini ( articles ) | Nov 17, 2026
Editor’s note: This memoir has been very lightly fictionalized, in part to prevent some individuals from being identified.
How I came to be in Somers State Prison twenty-something years ago is a long story; for brevity’s sake let’s call it a youthful indiscretion. How I came to find myself in F Block in January of 2005 is a shorter story, but let’s just call it a misunderstanding. That Michael Ross and I both found ourselves there together for that week was an oddity of bureaucracy.
The death chamber at Somers was built in 1963 when the Wethersfield State Prison was closed and became what is now the headquarters of the Connecticut DMV. The last man executed in the state was Joseph “Mad Dog” Taborsky, who, speaking of bureaucratic oddities, was the only man in the state ever sentenced to death twice. He was the last to go in the old electric chair at Wethersfield State Prison.
The sixties being what they were, the death chamber sat pristine and unused for several decades as New England lost its taste for vengeance. The death penalty remained on the books, rarely but occasionally meted out symbolically to the worst of the worst. A dozen or so men lived there on F Block for decades, drifting slowly through an endless series of appeals and the death chamber sat silent at the end of the long corridor of steel barred cells. When they built the new Northern Correctional SuperMax down the road, they moved death row there and didn’t even bother to build a new death chamber to replace the old one.
By the turn of the century, the death penalty was a polite fiction, and everyone played along. Until Michael Ross didn’t.
I didn’t know Michael Ross, but Eastern Connecticut is a small place. Small towns. Everybody knew somebody who knew someone he’d killed. Familiar French names, Baribeault, Dupais. We knew the pond behind Our Lady of LaSalette where they said he’d left one girl strangled and raped, where he’d been baptized as a kid. We knew the egg farm where he was raised. I remembered sneaking inside with my friends leading the way, murmuring horror stories about the mentally retarded wards of the state who lived and worked there. I heard they rape the chickens, my friend whispered. I heard Michael Ross caught them in the act once, and they did it to him too. That’s why he was like that.
I remembered the heat and the stink of the noise of the coops, narrow corridors of cages stacked on top of each other, conveyor belts lowered with chicken droppings and eggs and dead birds towards the sorting bay. I remembered running away into the woods of Brooklyn as one of the slow boys hollered at us from his shack. I remembered my heart beating out of my chest and looking over my shoulder, the faded plastic seventies LOVE sign in the window of the “retard shack” shrinking as we fled. I remembered all of it the day they walked Michael Ross through the narrow corridors of cages that was F Block.
Now death row had moved across the street, but the death chamber remained, almost forgotten at the end of that long corridor. The state in its wisdom chose not to build a second one to remain unused, but maintained the first, as execution was still the law of the land if only on paper. In the meantime, F Block had become what was called a Segregation Unit, colloquially known as The Hole. And so it remained until the day Michael Ross called their bluff.
Michael Ross had been born and baptized Catholic, but was long lapsed from the Church when he began stalking and murdering young girls he found on the side of the road. He’d returned to the faith in prison, as many do, and began writing for liberal Catholic publications about his life on death row. One self-pitying screed had the distinction of being rejected by Commonweal before America Magazine finally printed it, where it attracted the attention of several priests, including a progressive Benedictine who lived in a monastic order of one and an anti-death-penalty parish priest. They took up the cause of Ross’ spiritual direction and begin visiting with him regularly. He was confirmed. He began saying the rosary daily. He was a model inmate, a success story, a paragon of the anti-death penalty movement; until the day he discerned that he deserved what he had coming.
Ross waived his appeals. He ordered his lawyer to enter into a pact with the prosecutor. The state found itself in the position, forty-something years after Mad Dog fried in the old Wethersfield State Prison, of having to use its abandoned death chamber. There was nothing to do but move Ross back from the Northern Supermax to Somers State Prison, long since downgraded to a medium security facility. The southern corridor, where the death chamber was, was emptied of inmates to make way for Ross. The northern corridor remained The Hole, full of miscreants who found a way to go to jail even inside jail and victims of misunderstandings such as myself.
After about two days on the north side, the captain called me into his office and sat me down in a chair across from his desk and informed me that there had indeed been a misunderstanding, and I did not belong there. Unfortunately for me, about six months ago I had been downgraded to minimum security and, through an oversight, had not been transferred. I no longer belonged anywhere in Somers. They couldn’t just send me back to my unit. It could be a liability if anything happened. On the other hand, there were no beds available at the minimum-security prison at the moment. It could be up to a week. I was in limbo. Fortunately for me, I had arrived at the perfect moment in time. I wasn’t alone. There was another man in limbo, another whose classification eluded the neat bureaucratic order. We were two peas in a pod, the Captain said.
And so it came to pass that Michael Ross and I came to be the sole residents of the makeshift medium security death row at Somers State Prison in January of 2005.
We never spoke. I saw him come and go once. There were visitors but I couldn’t make out what was being said down at the far end of the corridor by the death chamber. Mostly I sat and stared and read the same three books cover to cover, over and over. No one seemed to know I existed. Meals came late, usually after I started wondering if they were coming at all. At some point in that week, Sister Helen Prejean came to see Michael and to persuade him to fight for his life. She compared his pact with the prosecutor to assisted suicide, but he was undeterred. He told her about his vision of death, Christ awaiting him at the gates of heaven, the Holy Spirit descending upon him and taking away the shame and the intrusive thoughts. He appealed to Bishop Hart, who reluctantly conceded that it was not a sin to accept a lawful punishment.
Undeterred, Prejean appealed privately to his lawyer as a Catholic. Unable to persuade him privately, she publicly denounced the attorney as a coward, calling him “the only movable piece in a machinery of death.” Protesters began to gather, on both sides, but mostly in defense of the man who did not want to be defended. In the final hour, Prejean and her lawyers could not stop Ross, but they did persuade a judge to threaten his attorney’s license to practice law if evidence later showed there was any doubt of Ross’ competence. A seething and tearful Ross finally relented to save his lawyer. The killer and the families of his victims stood uneasily against his father and the activist nuns and civil libertarians trying to save him. The execution was postponed pending a federal appeal. Oblivious to all of this, on the eighth day I was shipped off to the minimum-security prison in Niantic.
I arrived in Niantic in late January, the doldrums of deep winter in New England. Compared to the claustrophobic tiers of cells of old Somers, it was practically idyllic; an outdoors campus near the beach. Most days you could smell the ocean water blowing in off the sound. I ran into an old friend there, Johnny from Thompson, and we spent the cold days walking the yard mostly alone, the only white boys from the Eastern woods and crazy enough to volunteer for outdoor recreation in the winter. We threw bread at the seagulls and blared the Smiths on cassette out of headphones hanging loosely on my neck and mostly I didn’t think about Ross or death row or the chicken coops and the horrible things that happened in the woods behind the church. Occasionally an Old Franciscan from the friary down the road would stride across campus on the way to say mass in his grey habit, oversized rosary dangling like a whip and for a moment I’d remember all of it, but then Johnny would make a joke of it like he did everything, and I’d forget. You think he uses that thing to beat himself on the back for penance? he laughed. Those guys are hardcore, brother! It was a strangely peaceful time.
Catholicism had twice shattered my peace in prison before that winter in Niantic. The first time had been my grandfather’s death. I was called into an office and unceremoniously informed that he had died suddenly and quietly in his sleep. I was required to assure the Lieutenant that I was not going to kill myself, given a moment to compose myself, and sent back to my unit. A few days later I was placed in five-point restraints and driven in a minivan by two officers to the my grandparents’ church, where the wake was to occur later that evening. I had spoken to my grandparents very little in the years immediately preceding jail, hadn’t voluntarily set foot in a church for even longer, and was stunned by the weight of it all. I fell to my knees almost against my will where his body lay in repose before the altar, flanked by corrections officers. It was silent except for the jangling of my shackles.
The second time had come a year or so later, in Somers. The clerk of the Catholic chapel, a guy we called Pink who looked like a Foghat roadie and was doing a long stretch for robbing banks for junk, had heard I could play guitar. He guessed by my last name that I was Catholic or at least born that way. The choir needed a guitarist and he could pull strings if I was interested. I was reluctant, but hadn’t touched a guitar in years, and convinced myself it might not be so bad. I might not have believed in God, but maybe it was getting a little harder to believe in the nihilistic shibboleths of punk rock atheism either, at that point.
Pink called me down to the chapel office, where I met with him and Deacon Lanteri. I didn’t really know the difference between a deacon and a priest at the time, and thought to myself that Lanteri didn’t seem like any priest I’d ever met. He had a shaved head, a neat goatee, and a little gold ring pirate earring in his left year; a far cry from the stern old men with names like Monseigneur Castonguay at my grandparent’s parish. He asked me a few questions but didn’t seem bothered by my lack of faith, chiding me to keep an open mind as he had Pink walk me through the Chapel of Saint Dismas and relearn my Catholic manners. He walked me down the center aisle, lined on either side by mid-century industrial columns and stone and stained glass, to an altar where statues of the good thief and Mary flanked Christ on his cross, where he reminded me to kneel and then handed me the worst guitar I’ve ever played. Try not to break a string, he said. Replacing them is a whole thing.
For a while, it wasn’t a bad deal. The music wasn’t great. Deacon Lanteri liked the sappy seventies folk mass stuff my grandparents had hated and I’d spent my life avoiding, but on the other hand I got to play guitar. Occasionally we’d screw around at practice and do Beatles or Stones until Pink came out of the office and yelled at us, and then in November we shifted gears towards Christmas music and I actually started to like it. We were beginning to assemble the pieces of a Christmas mass to be celebrated by the bishop, the centerpiece of which would be a solo of Ave Maria by Tommy, an old lifer on the choir. Tommy didn’t say much. I’d made the mistake once of asking him when he got out, to which he just replied “never.” But he could sing.
One day in early December, we were practicing it and came to Tommy’s part. The rest of us just sat in the empty chapel and watched him sing. I’m sure I’d heard Ave Maria a thousand times before that day and a thousand times since, but that was the first time I think I’d ever really listened. I didn’t understand a word of Latin and still am not sure I could tell you why it affected me, but it did. I kept thinking of my grandfather in his casket and the line from O Holy Night we’d been practicing: Fall on your knees. I had to turn my head to surreptitiously wipe a tear, and when I looked up I saw Pink and Deacon Lanteri sitting in a back pew, Deacon’s arm outstretched and his finger playfully twirling Pink’s hair. Pink in return gently tugged the man’s earring. I felt the weight again, this time in the pit of my stomach. I never said anything but I never came back.
A week later, Pink showed up at my door angrily demanding an explanation. I had none. He called me a punk and a faggot and said he was never doing me a favor again and no one else would either. A week later, he got caught dubbing cassette tapes in his office, and saved his own skin by pointing the finger at me. Search his cell, he said. You’ll find a dubbed copy of Best of the Smiths. They did, and like a fool I followed the code and kept my mouth shut. They took me to F Block. The Hole. It was all a big misunderstanding.
A third encounter with Catholicism came in spring of 2005 at that minimum-security prison in Niantic. The peace was already tenuous. As the weather warmed, the yard became crowded and noisy and my walks with Johnny were no longer quiet. Michael Ross was in the news again. He’d won his federal appeal and no obstacles remained. The execution was on again for May.
Around this time I was abruptly called to the religious services building. I hadn’t set foot in a prison chapel or even given it much thought (beyond the occasional appearance of the friars) for months, so I was confused and apprehensive as I entered. The guard at the front told me Sister Margaret wanted to see me and directed me towards a classroom. A pleasant old woman was waiting for me in a sweater and khakis: she didn’t look like any kind of nun I’d ever seen, but Deacon Lanteri hadn’t looked like any kind of priest either. She introduced herself as a Sister of Mercy, told me her printer was broken and she’d heard I was good at fixing printers. At this point I was working at the prison print shop, and figured my boss must have given her my name. I reinstalled some drivers and rebooted her computer, and while it reloaded, she raised one hand over the printer and asked me to hold the other. We stood there and she prayed. She prayed for the printer, she prayed for me, she prayed for Michael Ross. She prayed for Sister Helen Prejean and the end to the death penalty, and she prayed for an end to the racism that drove it. She asked me if I knew about the Michael Ross case, and I said yes but kept to myself how well I knew it. She told me that the Sisters of Mercy worked closely with Sister Helen and that she was a great woman and that if we had faith she would prevail. Faith always prevailed. The printer came back to life and she said see? She told me I was a saint. I laughed and said I’d never heard that before.
Sister Helen did not prevail. The next week, one day after breakfast, we were ordered to our bunks and the entire campus was placed on restricted movement. They ordered the televisions off and dimmed the lights. We talked and played cards quietly until bed, then awoke the next day to the news that Michael Ross had died at 2:35am that morning in the death chamber at old Somers State Prison.
I don’t know if Sister Helen Prejean believed in hell when she told Michael Ross he would go there for allowing the state to murder him. I don’t know if Michael Ross really believed deep down in his heart that Christ was waiting for him in spite of it all, if he really believed the Holy Spirit could wash it all away. Two days after his death, the psychiatric expert who testified against his competence on behalf of Sister Helen received a taunting note from Ross that read simply: “Check, and mate. You never had a chance!” Had it all been a game to him? Or was it just frustration at the activists who had hijacked his free will, questioned his sanity and intelligence to preserve his human dignity, or at the spiritual advisers who told him to pray but didn’t like how the prayers were answered?
I don’t know how the boy from the egg farm in my Eastern woods ended up at Cornell, hunting co-eds for sport, or why he came home to pick on girls like Wendy Baribeault. I don’t know how Sister Helen famously couldn’t stomach a meeting with President Bush, but could sit across from Michael Ross, who’d had every opportunity in life to do anything besides murder young girls. To paraphrase the sister, speaking to his “callous indifference” as governor of Texas, what sort of conversation is possible? In the end, she may have been right, in a way. The conversation with Ross was fruitless. He was, as she speculated the president might be, unmoved by her pleas for mercy.
Twenty-something years later, I sit at my desk in the office of a soup kitchen. It was founded by Sister Margaret and her order, and abandoned years later as they felt compelled to venture into politics, moved by Sister Helen’s testimony and minor celebrity. There isn’t much evidence that they were ever here, but for a plaque on my wall bearing her name and the names of some of her fellow sisters.
I found my way back to the Church a few years after leaving this all behind, feeling the sudden urge to attend a Latin mass. I still think of Tommy in the chapel of Saint Dismas when I hear the old Marian hymns. I still think of Deacon Lanteri when there is scandal in the church. I think of Pink whenever someone does the right thing for the wrong reason, and Sister Helen whenever someone does the wrong thing for the right reason. Most of all I think about Michael. I still don’t know what to think, but I think about him a lot.
And he said to Jesus: Lord, remember me when thou shalt come into thy kingdom.
And Jesus said to him: Amen I say to thee, this day thou shalt be with me in paradise.
And it was almost the sixth hour; and there was darkness over all the earth until the ninth hour.
Next post
All comments are moderated. To lighten our editing burden, only current donors are allowed to Sound Off. If you are a current donor, log in to see the comment form; otherwise please support our work, and Sound Off!



