two scandals, one theme
By Diogenes (articles ) | Jul 28, 2010
Newsweek has jumped all over a report by Italian journalist Carmelo Abbate, whose undercover reporting produced a sensational story about the homosexual dalliances of Catholic priests in Rome. Cardinal Agostino Vallini, the Pope’s vicar for the Rome diocese, responded to the story by challenging the homosexual priests to get out of the closet and out of the clergy. But Newsweek and its source are not convinced.
The exposé has touched a nerve within the Catholic community in Rome, but Abbate doesn’t believe that it will have any effect, especially given the Vatican’s other sex scandal.
Wait; what’s this? The “other” sex scandal? What scandal is that? Most of the Newsweek story is devoted to an explanation of a distinction that many readers could otherwise miss.
Vallini may have the right idea when it comes to punishing those who break priestly laws, but the church as a whole seems to find it difficult to differentiate its sex scandals—and to determine what role celibacy plays in either situation.
Newsweek will help us to differentiate, you see. And Newsweek has already dropped a broad hint, announcing that celibacy plays a role and implicitly criticizing Church leaders for their failure to address that role. No evidence is introduced to support the notion that celibacy is a major cause of the problem, yet no other factor is introduced at this point in the story. Later Newsweek trots out a few other, presumably lesser, factors:
In fact, the two sex scandals are vastly different. The gay priest problem is about celibacy, church law, and hypocrisy. The pedophile problem is about child abuse, criminal behavior, and abuses of power.
While doggedly sympathetic toward homosexual priests, Newsweek does let slip the fact that “90 percent of sex-abuse cases do involve priests and adolescent boys.” Criminal behavior, yes. Abuse, certainly. Child abuse, maybe. Pedophilia, no.
Newsweek perceives two scandals. One involves priests who have sex with young males. The other involves priests who have sex with even younger males. One involves priests who have illicit relations with strangers they meet at gay bars. The other involves priests who have illicit relations with teenagers they meet in their parish work. These are “vastly different,” you must understand.
Yet Newsweek reporters, trained to recognize the key issues in a story, have identified one thread of similarity between these two scandals. It's all a question of... celibacy
An appeal from our founder, Dr. Jeffrey Mirus:
Dear reader: If you found the information on this page helpful in your pursuit of a better Catholic life, please support our work with a donation. Your donation will help us reach seven million Truth-seeking readers worldwide this year. Thank you!
All comments are moderated. To lighten our editing burden, only current donors are allowed to Sound Off. If you are a donor, log in to see the comment form; otherwise please support our work, and Sound Off!
Posted by: mclom2107 -
Jul. 31, 2010 9:13 AM ET USA
Dear Editor, There's no doubt that quite a lot of people have a problem with Jesus' own words that, in spite of every effort, the gates of hell will not overcome the Church He founded. He is present in our Church on many levels but especially in the Blessed Sacrament. My son recently met an ex-Muslim converted directly by Jesus when the young man had several unusual interior experiences each time he drove past or parked outside a RC church. He went inside one day to investigate... Praise God!
Posted by: Frodo1945 -
Jul. 29, 2010 5:53 PM ET USA
Di, I appreciate your comments but this business in Rome is a scandal, and Newsweek didn't cause it. The purification of the Church continues. (note that I didn't say self-purification) All those ugly hidden things are coming to the light and it is not pretty.
Posted by: Gil125 -
Jul. 28, 2010 4:23 PM ET USA
It may be more basic than that. It may be that it's a question of...the Catholic Church.