can't tell the players without a program
By Diogenes (articles ) | Apr 22, 2004
MEMRI lists a number of reactions to Gibson's Passion from the Arab world, some predictable, others not. In the latter category belongs this comment by Hani Naqshabandi, identified as the "editor of the Saudi family magazine Sayyidaty":
The real irritation in the film is that it revealed a lie that we, the Arabs, tell ourselves everyday. This lie is that we are hated in the world because the Jews control Hollywood, the film industry, and the entertainment industry in America. ... I am not saying that they [the Jews] have no impact or influence. They do indeed, but not as we think or claim, and not as we imagined when we accused the Jews, Hollywood, and the Zionist lobby here and there for our failure to communicate with others. This is not a defense of the Jews or a promotion for the film, but an attempt to reveal that we must stop accusing others for our mistakes.
The author's (fairly modest) claim is that the film could never have been made if Zionist power in Hollywood were absolute. In ignorance of the status and political orientation within Saudi life of the publication and its editor, it's impossible to know whether this is centrist or fringe thinking, or even to which fringe it might belong. As always, the question is: whom do we trust to put it in context for us?
All comments are moderated. To lighten our editing burden, only current donors are allowed to Sound Off. If you are a donor, log in to see the comment form; otherwise please support our work, and Sound Off!
Posted by: -
Apr. 22, 2004 9:24 AM ET USA
The Saudi leadership which is strict Wahhabist is the norm. I suspect Hani will recieve the classic whooping after Jummah prayers to clear his thinking and assure he stays tightly qued to the party line; that muslim are rightly guided and donot lie to themselves. Maybe the whooping will happen prior to Jummah, never the less; Hani will get qued.
Posted by: extremeCatholic -
Apr. 22, 2004 9:12 AM ET USA
Anti-semitism, anti-Christian, and anti-secularist propaganda must continue to be fueled because if that isn't the focus of their hatred, the Arab street might come to the real truth that they have been exploited and held back by a corrupt oligarchy. The failure of the Arab world to advance can't be attributed to the current leadership of the Arab world, so the Jews are blamed. It's just that simple.