Your gift counts double until 5/31: $27,245 to go in our Easter Campaign. Please help now!
 The City Gates

Brief, off-the-cuff, and sometimes light-hearted Catholic commentary, observations and announcements.

Making Sense of Society: The Ebook by Dr. Jeff Mirus - Tuesday

We've released a new ebook at shop.catholicculture.org. It is a collection of my essays over the past six years on Catholic social teaching and the problems we face in orchestrating the social order. See Making Sense of Society. Collecting essays which deal with social principles is no easy task....

An exorcism? No, a blessing. You'd think reporters would know the difference. by Phil Lawler - Tuesday

As you watch, a priest places his hands on a man’s head and prays silently for a few seconds. What did you just witness? A blessing, right? That wasn’t a tough question. Pretty basic, for anyone with even a passing knowledge of Catholic practices. But that’s not how reporters...

Learning from the sick, and from the death of a child by Phil Lawler - Friday

This past Tuesday we buried Sheila Catherine Beirne, a sweet 6-year-old girl who succumbed to Leigh’s Disease. The Beirnes are a big happy Catholic family, with a deep faith and a wide circle of friends. The church was packed for the funeral, with brothers and sisters and aunts and uncles and...

The case for change in Irish abortion law: based on a framework of falsehood by Phil Lawler - Friday

Irish Prime Minister Enda Kenny has outdone himself with the claim that the legislation advanced by his government, which would allow for legal abortion in some circumstances, “obviously doesn’t change the legislation on abortion.” The proposal advanced by Kenny obviously does...

Too many missing funds: Catholic institutions need tighter financial controls by Phil Lawler - Thursday

Frankly I’m tired of reading stories like this one, about people who have stolen money from Catholic dioceses, parishes, and schools. It’s time—it’s long past time, actually—for some tighter financial controls. For years I served on the board of an ecumenical initiative: a pregnancy-help...

Pope Francis: Counter-Cultural? by Dr. Jeff Mirus - May 13, 2013

Please read and reflect on our little story about Pope Francis refusing to allow photo-ops to communicants guilty of public scandal. You may recall that, under different circumstances, this is exactly the issue which both Phil Lawler and I raised when USCCB President...

$3 billion and counting: the sex-abuse scandal continues by Phil Lawler - May 10, 2013

If you read today’s top CWN headline quickly, you might have come away with the impression that the total costs of the sex-abuse scandal to American dioceses has been $2.62 billion. That’s not quite right. If you read the headline carefully, you’d notice that the $2.62 billion...

Phil Lawler's new book at steep discounts! by Dr. Jeff Mirus - May 9, 2013

Would people in your parish/school/organization enjoy a beautifully illustrated book about Pope Francis and the conclave that chose him? Are you looking for appropriate gifts for graduates? For a Confirmation class? Do you want to stock up early on Christmas and/or birthday presents? A Call to...

If the pastor is asked to resign, what about the archbishop? by Phil Lawler - May 8, 2013

A pastor in the Trenton diocese has resigned--apparently at his bishop’s request—because he allowed Father Michael Fugee to join in youth-ministry activities, despite an agreement with prosecutors that barred Fugee from unsupervised contact with children. There might be a message...

If only the Vatican were open to the Gospel… by Dr. Jeff Mirus - May 7, 2013

The defense of the Leadership Conference for Women Religious by the president of the International Union of Superiors General would be funny if it were intended as a parody. Read the story and you’ll see what I mean. According to Sister Mary Lou Wirtz, the problem is simple: Since Vatican...

In a preposterous Vatican statement, one important revelation by Phil Lawler - May 7, 2013

Today’s bizarre public statement from the Vatican press office, denying what any intelligent observer recognizes as the truth, does contain one nugget of reality. The statement denies that there has been any difference of opinion between Cardinal Braz de Aviz and Archbishop Müller,...

Criticizing cardinals for things they never said by Phil Lawler - May 6, 2013

For reasons I don’t fully understand, weekends always seem to bring out the most egregious distortions in media coverage of the Catholic Church. Consequently, on Mondays I often feel obliged to warn readers about stories that are misleading, or just plain false. Today I’ll highlight...

Released: Ordinary Time After Easter by Dr. Jeff Mirus - May 2, 2013

Volume 5 of the current 2012-2013 liturgical year series has just been released. It covers the first half of the long stretch of Ordinary Time between Easter and Advent, namely May 20 through August 24th. The final volume 6 will be released in early August. You can purchase and download any...

Pope Benedict, cats, and red shoes by Phil Lawler - May 2, 2013

The next time someone tells you that Benedict XVI was an authoritarian Pontiff, or that he lived in luxury in the papal apartments, remind him that the former Pope, a renowned cat-lover, didn’t keep a cat during his pontificate. Why not? Because he was told cats weren’t allowed in the...

Sin, the Devil, and Pope Francis by Phil Lawler - May 2, 2013

Veteran reporters (myself included) are wrestling with the question of how to cover the homilies delivered by Pope Francis at Mass each day in the Domus Sanctae Marthae. We’re all accustomed to seeing formal statements from the Pontiff, but these daily meditations, delivered...

Carnegie-Mellon: Community Bankruptcy? by Dr. Jeff Mirus - May 2, 2013

Then there’s this from our Catholic World News service yesterday: “At a campus parade sponsored by the Carnegie-Mellon art department, a female undergraduate marched wearing a costume meant to resemble that of the Pope, while naked from the waist down. She distributed condoms along the parade...

Hoist on their own petards by Phil Lawler - May 1, 2013

In two different stories covered by today’s CWNews headlines, a rebuke from a Catholic bishop prompts a truly absurd defense. Consider first the case of Carnegie-Mellon University, whose administrators are not yet ready to concede that an undergraduate should be disciplined for parading on...

Was abortion always the motivating factor behind Obamacare? by Phil Lawler - Apr 29, 2013

For months the American bishops struggled mightily to convince President Obama that he should exclude abortion coverage from his health-care plan. Did they ever have a chance? The question may be moot now. Still let's pursue it, if only for the sake of the historical record. You already know...

At last a halfway accurate report on a Womenpriests charade by Phil Lawler - Apr 29, 2013

At last someone got it right. A Reuters report on the latest ceremony staged by “Roman Catholic Womenpriests” begins this way: "In an emotional ceremony filled with tears and applause, a 70-year-old Kentucky woman was ordained a priest on Saturday as part of a dissident group...

At Boston's bombing scene: Catholic priests need not apply by Phil Lawler - Apr 26, 2013

Writing in the Wall Street Journal, Jennifer Graham tells me something that I hadn’t heard about Boston Marathon bombing. As dozens of victims were sprawled across Boylston Street, many of them in danger of death, Catholic priests came running to the scene—and were turned...

Marini on Same-Sex Unions: Currying Favor with Pope Francis? by Dr. Jeff Mirus - Apr 24, 2013

Archbishop Piero Marini’s support for legal recognition of same-sex unions is interesting for several reasons. Marini is the president of the Pontifical Committee for International Eucharistic Congresses, and he made his statements in an interview in connection with the current National...

Now in print! by Phil Lawler - Apr 23, 2013

A Call to Serve, which I co-authored with Stefan von Kempis of Vatican Radio, is now off the press, headed for the warehouses, and will be available to readers within a few days. In a short, richly illustrated book, you'll find personal background on Pope Francis, his early life, his vision for...

Cardinal O'Malley's missed opportunity by Phil Lawler - Apr 23, 2013

“We must build a civilization of love, or there will be no civilization at all,” said Boston’s Cardinal Sean O’Malley, at a Mass for the repose of the souls of those killed in the Marathon bombing. So far, so good. But then the wheels came off. Pointing to sources of the...

That inefficient administration in Rome, led by an old man... by Phil Lawler - Apr 22, 2013

It seems that I spoke too soon. After I poked fun at the Italian politicians who couldn’t put together a new government, they took the first step, selecting a new president. Well, not really. They called back the old president, persuading him to begin serving a new term at the age of...

A bishop's questionable expertise on gun-control legislation by Phil Lawler - Apr 22, 2013

While Bishop Blaire laments the failure of the US Senate to approve new gun-control regulations, could we inject a dash of political reality into the discussion? The Senate did not vote against gun-control legislation. On the contrary, a majority voted in favor. So why didn’t the measure pass?...

Benedict XVI in retirement: a total, prudent silence by Phil Lawler - Apr 19, 2013

Just six weeks ago, some “experts” on Vatican affairs were predicting that confusion was bound to arise in the Catholic world when we had two living Popes. Well, let me ask you: Do you feel confused? Today we mark the 8th anniversary of the election of Benedict XVI as Supreme Pontiff. Many...

If you think a conclave is inefficient, what about the Italian parliament? by Phil Lawler - Apr 18, 2013

Remember back during the conclave, when secular commentators were scoffing at the “ridiculous,” antiquated, inefficient way the Catholic Church chooses a Pope? Well, we’ve had our new Pope for a month now, and things seem to be working out just fine, thank you. Meanwhile the thoroughly modern...

Adopt a Supreme Court Justice by Dr. Jeff Mirus - Apr 16, 2013

We get lots of mail here at CatholicCulture.org. For example, today I received an email from somebody named Nathaniel Wenger, the purpose of which was to advocate a new form of government, far superior to democracy, which Nate modestly calls Wengerocracy. Um...OK. But I also received this...

Two columnists show how the Gosnell case threatens the 'pro-choice' stand by Phil Lawler - Apr 16, 2013

Yesterday while I was trying to draw the key lesson from the Gosnell trial, two other columnists were demonstrating that if this horrible story makes people stop and think, the facile public acceptance of unrestricted-abortion-on-demand will end. James Taranto of the Wall Street Journal...

Lent before Easter: Small Decisions, Major Consequences by Dr. Jeff Mirus - Apr 11, 2013

It isn’t light reading, but some of us glance through each issue of the Fellowship of Catholic Scholars Quarterly. In the latest, E. Christian Brugger has an intriguing article entitled “Free Choice, Self-Determination and Contraceptive Acts”. Brugger holds the J. Francis...

Was St. Stanislaus comfortable? by Phil Lawler - Apr 11, 2013

On this feast of St. Stanislaus I can’t help wondering whether the great Polish bishop and martyr was “comfortable” confronting King Boleslaus. The foes of St. Stanislaus said that the bishop was playing politics when he excommunicated the king. That argument has a very contemporary flavor,...

The 'Pope Francis effect'-- longer lines for Confession? by Phil Lawler - Apr 9, 2013

Vatican Insider says that Italian priests are reporting more people coming to Confession since the election of Pope Francis—including many people who have been away from the sacrament for a long time. American priests have told me the same thing, and it seems to me the lines have been a bit...

A proposal for curial reform: break up the Vatican Secretariat of State by Phil Lawler - Apr 8, 2013

“Reform of the Roman Curia” was the cry of the day—among journalists, at least—in the days before the conclave that elected Pope Francis. So now with the new Pope settling into his work, commentators are speculating on the sort of changes that the Holy Father might...

Wondering where I've been? by Phil Lawler - Apr 2, 2013

You may have noticed that during the last 10 days before Easter, I posted virtually no editorial commentary on this site. A few friends wrote to ask whether I was ill, or on vacation. Far from it. I was working, hammer and tongs, on a special project:  A Call to Serve: Pope Francis and...

Red shoes, the papal apartments, and Petrine authority by Phil Lawler - Apr 1, 2013

Let's see if I understand this correctly: You say you can't respect the authority of Pope Francis because, by not moving quickly into the apostolic palace, he's denigrating the authority of the papacy? So it's the apartments that make the difference?  St. Peter didn't live in the papal...

SNAP praises bishop, defends Church by Phil Lawler - Apr 1, 2013

The Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP) has issued a statement praising diocesan bishops who have responded energetically to the sex-abuse crisis, and voicing loyalty to the teachings of the Catholic Church. The SNAP statement said: April Fool! (No such statement has ever been...

The Supreme Court - About to Play God Again? by Chris Pelicano - Mar 27, 2013

Matching Books to Readers, II: Stroik’s The Church Building as a Sacred Place by Dr. Jeff Mirus - Mar 21, 2013

Duncan Stroik has, over the past several decades, led a crusade to restore a sense of the sacred to Church architecture, gradually forcing the Modernists into retreat and establishing a beachhead of spaces clearly set apart for God for the purpose of communicating the mysteries of Faith. A...

Matching Books to Readers, I: Monti’s A Sense of the Sacred by Dr. Jeff Mirus - Mar 21, 2013

Occasionally a truly fine book will come across my desk which deserves to be more widely known, meriting close and enthusiastic reading by a particular Catholic audience, but which simply does not cover a subject in which I have the requisite personal interest. Two perfect examples have...

A 'must' read on a horrifying topic by Phil Lawler - Mar 20, 2013

Mark Steyn’s stinging commentary on the routinized killing at Kermit Gosnell’s abortion clinic is a “must” read. As Steyn remarks, despite the appalling evidence that has come out during Gosnell's trial—including admissions of deliberate killing, and blood-curdling...

Want more commentary? Visit the Archives.

Think with the Catholic Leaders: Subscribe to Catholic Culture Insights Newsletter
Donate to Support this Site: Your contribution will be put to good work.
Tour the CatholicCulture.org Site
Shop Amazon to Raise Money for Catholic Culture

Recent Catholic Commentary

The Mystery of the Spirit 13 hours ago
Against a Facile Assurance of Salvation, the Need for Mystery 15 hours ago
Making Sense of Society: The Ebook 20 hours ago
An exorcism? No, a blessing. You'd think reporters would know the difference. 22 hours ago
Learning from the sick, and from the death of a child May 17

Top Catholic News

Most Important Stories of the Last 30 Days
Pope strongly supports call for reform in religious life CWN - May 8