Click here to advertise on

Loss & Gain

By Diogenes (articles ) | Sep 28, 2003

The First Amendment protects Erie Bishop Donald Trautman's denunciation of three putative whistleblowers, Judge William Cunningham ruled Tuesday. Sally Beres, Ann Caro, and Helen Rusnak had claimed that Trautman slandered them by characterizing them as liars.

The background is wearyingly familiar. Father Bob was into naughty pix. Beres claims she lost her secretary's job because she reported the fact to the Diocese. Now-retired Bishop Murphy, whom Beres says she told about Father Bob, has no memory of the meeting. When Beres and her comrades went public to claim a cover-up, the current bishop trashed the allegation as "outrageous." The Erie Times-News reports:

Cunningham ruled only on the issue at hand -- whether the bishops defamed the women. "In this case, it is not the role of the court to determine whether the Diocese of Erie appropriately handled any alleged improprieties with any priest; or to hold the bishops accountable for any alleged failure to act," Cunningham wrote.

We can imagine that Trautman and Murphy were not the only prelates to heave a sigh of relief at the outcome of the case: they are declared free to characterize their accusers as slanderers -- without having to prove the falsehood of the accusation against them. Of course, this is a double-edged ruling. Innocent victims of malicious accusations have more freedom to counter-attack, while villains have greater latitude in the execution of their villainy.

So Trautman and Murphy won. Beres, Caro, and Rusnak lost. But the disputed facts at the root of the scandal have yet to be sorted out, and the "importunate widows" of the future will be unlikely to repeat the blunder of seeking justice in the manner naively suggested by charity, prudence, and mercy -- namely, by approaching their bishop discreetly and in good faith. As Stephen Brady has shown, if you want action, you go to the Action News Team first. When the bishops see the contents of Father's hard drive splashed on News at Nine, then the problem will take on reality for them.

The slide into cynicism is potentially reversible. If it were important to them, bishops and religious superiors could investigate incipient scandals more quickly and more thoroughly than any detective or prosecutor or journalist. They could act, and act decisively, long before gossip had a chance to travel to the chancery water-coolers. Such alacrity would result in sudden vacancies in the ranks of bishops, priests, and seminary faculty. There'd be no more mega-meetings in hotel conference centers, no more public relations-driven awareness programs, no more transparently bogus happy-talk for the Klieg lights.

If it were important to them.

An appeal from our founder, Dr. Jeffrey Mirus:

Dear reader: If you found the information on this page helpful in your pursuit of a better Catholic life, please support our work with a donation. Your donation will help us reach seven million Truth-seeking readers worldwide this year. Thank you!

Our Spring Challenge Grant
Progress toward our Spring Challenge Grant goal ($25,000 to go):
$25,000.00 $0.00
100% 0%
Sound Off! supporters weigh in.

All comments are moderated. To lighten our editing burden, only current donors are allowed to Sound Off. If you are a donor, log in to see the comment form; otherwise please support our work, and Sound Off!

Show 1 Comments? (Hidden)Hide Comments
  • Posted by: extremeCatholic - Sep. 30, 2003 3:19 PM ET USA

    I can't imagine anyone discussing anything with these bishops without a tape recorder or independent witnesses being present ever again. What they have lost may be more than they have gained.

Subscribe for free
Click here to advertise on
Shop Amazon

Recent Catholic Commentary

The Essence of Evangelization 0 hours ago
The Finn resignation: 10 years too late, bishops face accountability 1 hours ago
Evangelization Itself 3 hours ago
Church Fathers: The Other Greek Apologists April 19
Mysteries, again and again! April 17

Top Catholic News

Most Important Stories of the Last 30 Days
Pope challenges world leaders' silence on persecution of Christians CWN - April 6
Pope outlines plans for the extraordinary jubilee of mercy CWN - April 13
Vatican completes doctrinal assessment of Leadership Conference of Women Religious CWN - April 16
Pope accepts resignation of Bishop Finn CWN - 13 hours ago