Louisiana court: woman may testify about what she said to priest in Confession
August 03, 2016
In a 2-1 ruling, a Louisiana appellate court has ruled that a woman whose family is suing the Diocese of Baton Rouge and one of its priests may testify about what she told the priest during Confession.
In his dissenting opinion, Judge Guy Holdridge wrote that “allowing Plaintiffs to mention, reference, or introduce evidence at trial of the confessions at issue will place an undue burden on Father [Jeff] Bayhi’s right to the free exercise of his religion and violates the constitutional command of separation of church and state.”
The ruling comes in a long-running case in which Father Jeff Bayhi had been directed to testify about what a 14-year-old eportedly told him in Confession. The young woman has said that she told Father Bayhi about being molested by a member of his parish. Father Bayhi had refused to testify, citing the inviolability of the confessional seal.
Earlier this year, a lower court ruled that the state law making priests mandated reporters of sexual abuse was unconstitutional insofar as it applied to confessions, since it violated religious freedom. That decision has been appealed to a different court.
In an earlier phase of the case, the Louisiana Supreme Court had said that Father Bayhi could be required to testify, because in this case the penitent had waived the protection of the confessional seal. Church officials pointed out that the seal cannot be waived, and a priest cannot reveal the contents of a confession under any circumstances. Last year the US Supreme Court had declined to hear the case.
- Appeals court: Woman can testify about what she claims she told Baton Rouge-area priest in confession about being sexually abused (Baton Rouge Advocate)
- Penitent May Testify To Her Statements To Priest In Confession (Religion Clause)
- Louisiana judge strikes down law that requires priest to report abuse mentioned in confession (CWN, 2/29)
All comments are moderated. To lighten our editing burden, only current donors are allowed to Sound Off. If you are a donor, log in to see the comment form; otherwise please support our work, and Sound Off!