more fire & ice
By Diogenes (articles ) | May 18, 2005
The NCR is continuing her heroine-lashed-to-the-traintracks aria this week, wailing about the episcopal villains that sacrificed America's Tom Reese to the CDF locomotive, in the hope that someone might find her worth tieing-up herself. There are a couple interesting anonymous sources quoted in the accompanying news story, however, giving fuller background to Reese's resignation.
There's also a story about a lay employee sacked by the Jesuit Conference (the U.S. Jesuits' national bureau) for a pro-homosexual article he wrote for the National Jesuit News. The article was taken down from the newsletter's online version but made available by the NCR. The author, Erik Meder, told the NCR that his article was said to cause "irreparable harm to the Society of Jesus in the United States" -- an odd judgment, inasmuch as the article, though conventionally contra doctrinam, scarcely differs in this respect from several pieces published in America by its Jesuit associate editor Fr. James Martin. It's interesting that Meder's article scrupulously avoids the term "gay" in reference to homosexuals.
Meder holds (or held) the wonderfully mysterious position of "outreach coordinator" for the Jesuit Conference's Office of Social and International Ministries. Currently a layman, he was once apparently a Jesuit seminarian, and it's hard to imagine that his employers were unaware of his enthusiasms. Perhaps, in view of the broader context of social ministry, the outreach in question was coordinated a little too well, or too often. I'm confident that the same commitment to transparency that deplores the operations of the CDF will labor ceaselessly to bring to light the real reasons behind Meder's multiple career changes.
All comments are moderated. To lighten our editing burden, only current donors are allowed to Sound Off. If you are a donor, log in to see the comment form; otherwise please support our work, and Sound Off!
Posted by: Fr. William -
May. 18, 2005 10:26 PM ET USA
In Meder's article in America he describes seeing himself in the "Other" and in the migrant... I would venture to guess that America's commitment to transparency will find that Meder's multiple career changes parallel the multiple partners of a gay lifestyle that he directly supports, busily coordinating the outreach...
Posted by: -
May. 18, 2005 10:02 PM ET USA
A couple of gems from the NCR links: "Perhaps it’s time the Gospel of homosexual clergy be proclaimed." I believe the last time that gospel was "proclaimed" it ended up costing U.S. dioceses hundreds of millions of dollars. "People are doing all sorts of things to protect themselves and to stay out of range of Rome’s radar. It was a sad week." --Hmm. Instead of trying to hide your dissent better, why not try actually accepting Church teaching? Then you won't have worry about Rome's radar.
Posted by: -
May. 18, 2005 8:47 AM ET USA
When people start talking about "circular dynamics" I have the distinct impression of a withering Chestertonian response that they are really just talking in circles. Mr. Meder's pathetic appeal to Scripture to provide legitimacy to his weird thesis is only the first of his mistakes. His position is so wrong on so many levels it is well that his article was not circulated. In fact the only 'circularity' I envision for it is: consignment to the 'circular file'. Done.