By Diogenes (articles ) | Feb 13, 2004
The most Rev. Thomas L. Dupre ... abruptly resigned yesterday as bishop of the Springfield Roman Catholic Diocese, citing health reasons.
Outstanding. Bishop Dupre bails out of his bishopric five years ahead of the statutory retirement age of 75 under the rubric of Canon 401, paragraph 2, "because of illness or some other grave reason." He thereby joins a distinguished group of other "dash-2" retirees: Bishop Keith Symons (presently 71 years old), Bishop Patrick Ziemann (62), Bishop Dan Ryan (73), Bishop Joseph Hart (72), and Bishop Anthony O'Connell (65). All of the above stood accused of illicit sexual relations, with males, at the time of their premature retirement.
What if, one wonders, a bishop really retired for reasons of ill health
Back in, say, 1973, both charity and common sense would have prompted us to assume that a bishop who announced ill health as the reason for his retirement suffered, in actual fact, from ill health, and that his illness was the true cause of his stepping down.
Times have changed. How much, you ask? Look at it this way: if you were a bishop who'd lived an upright life but had to exit tomorrow because of a dicky heart, wouldn't you make sure fifty or sixty of your episcopal confreres publicly attested to your probity? And if you were a bishop-friend of the man making the early exit, wouldn't you be downright eager to comply?
Is it ungenerous of us, before a case has been proven against him in a court of law, to class Dupre with other unsavory members of the boys-boys-boys brigade? Yep. But what goes around comes around: bureaucratic equivocation works both ways. We didn't give Dupre the dash-2 tag, the Congregation for Bishops did. And if his brother bishops believe we'd do Dupre an injustice in giving his dash-2 a negative interpretation, then it's their duty to instruct us
P.S. According to the Springfield Republican story linked above, "[Dupre's] ailments are not considered life threatening, according to diocesan officials."
We can all breathe easier.
All comments are moderated. To lighten our editing burden, only current donors are allowed to Sound Off. If you are a donor, log in to see the comment form; otherwise please support our work, and Sound Off!
Posted by: Mike128 -
Feb. 14, 2004 8:50 AM ET USA
St. Patrick's Day is just around the corner and I suspect he is rolling rapidly in his grave. Re: Diogenes above, and I ask him,has he noticed the high number of Irish names among the priests and bishops who are resigning for "health problems". Don't want to make this a racial issue, and I realize the high ratio of Irish priests in this country but somenthing seems amiss concerning the scandals and negative publicity concerning the Church and our Irish clergy.No offense meant to the Irish.
Posted by: -
Feb. 13, 2004 12:18 PM ET USA
Meanwhile, another bishop is beginning "treatment for a life-threatening form of leukemia." http://www.mlive.com/news/sanews/index.ssf?/base/news-9/1076685601168170.xml But he hasn't requested dash-2 status. Huh.
Posted by: Pseudodionysius -
Feb. 13, 2004 10:09 AM ET USA
Interesting juxatposition. The Pope struggles, daily, with serious physical ailments, but soldiers on, because he believes in the salvific value of suffering. Meanwhile, the Dash-2's are pitching their iron crosses and scapulars so quickly that there's a serious risk of a golf cart collision during tee-off time.