Commentary / Podcasts

Top 10 from Criteria: The Catholic Film Podcast for All Time

Community on the Margins: Stagecoach (1939) w/ Anthony Esolen by Criteria: The Catholic Film Podcast (From Jun 8, 2020) 60,335

John Ford’s Stagecoach is a classic of the American Western that both elevated the genre and catapulted the career of its breakout star, John Wayne. Well-known Catholic writer and cultural commentator, Anthony Esolen,...

Citizen Kane (1941) by Criteria: The Catholic Film Podcast (From Nov 29, 2022) 54,480

For decades critics said Orson Welles’s Citizen Kane was the greatest film ever made. Unfortunately, that intimidating label sometimes keeps people from sitting down and watching the thing. It needn’t be so. Kane is eminently watchable and entertaining. It also definitely...

Fatima (2020) by Criteria: The Catholic Film Podcast (From Aug 28, 2020) 31,067

Our first response to the new feature film based on the events surrounding Our Lady of Fatima’s appearance to Sts. Francisco and Jacinta Marto and Servant of God Sister Maria Lúcia in 1917. Official Fatima film website:

Sacrilege against Mary in the new Padre Pio film by Criteria: The Catholic Film Podcast (From Jun 1, 2023) 27,306

The new film Padre Pio, directed by Abel Ferrara and starring Shia LaBeouf, is ruined by a pornographic and sacrilegious scene involving abuse of a sacred image. James Majewski and Thomas Mirus contend that conscientious Catholics must not see this movie. They explain the difference...

We watched the WHOLE Vatican Film List by Criteria: The Catholic Film Podcast (From Jun 27, 2023) 19,717

Since starting Criteria: The Catholic Film Podcast in May 2020, we’ve been hosting in-depth discussions of movies from the Vatican’s 1995 list of important films. Now, after three years, we’ve finished discussing all 45 films—and in this episode, together with...

The Mission (1986) by Criteria: The Catholic Film Podcast (From Aug 13, 2021) 19,271

It’s remarkable that as recently as 1986, we had a hit movie, with A-list stars (Jeremy Irons, Robert De Niro) and an A-list composer (Ennio Morricone), that takes a nuanced look at a controversial historical subject, European Christian missionary activity. The Mission could not be made...

The Leopard (1963) by Criteria: The Catholic Film Podcast (From Feb 8, 2023) 18,788

The Leopard was one of the most popular Italian novels of the 20th century. An historical epic about a Sicilian prince who must navigate the social upheaval that came with Italy’s unification in the mid-19th century, it was written by a man who was in a position to know about fading...

Catholic review of The Chosen, Season 3 by Criteria: The Catholic Film Podcast (From Mar 13, 2023) 18,125

It’s time for another lively discussion of the wildly popular Christian TV series The Chosen, following on the release of its third season, which stretches from the sermon on the mount to the feeding of the five thousand. Since the show is written by Evangelical Protestants, Thomas and...

The Chosen, Season 2: characters and controversies by Criteria: The Catholic Film Podcast (From Oct 11, 2021) 16,298

Oratorian brother and visual artist Joshua Vargas joins Thomas and James to discuss Season 2 of The Chosen. The series continues to set a high imaginative standard in its portrayal of the Twelve Apostles, each of whom has a distinctive personality and several of whom have beautifully...

From Stage to Screen: A Man for All Seasons (1966) by Criteria: The Catholic Film Podcast (From Jun 19, 2020) 14,727

The film adaptation of Robert Bolt’s award-winning play about St. Thomas More, A Man for All Seasons, swept the floor at the Academy Awards, winning Best Picture, Best Director, Best Actor, Best Adapted Screenplay, Best...