No AI writing!

Commentary / Podcasts

Top 10 from Phil Lawler within the Last Year

Trump’s false charge against Pope Leo by Phil Lawler (From May 7, 2026) 41,307

President Trump has now made and repeated a blatant falsehood: that Pope Leo “thinks it’s just fine for Iran to have a nuclear weapon.” In a May 5 appearance on the Hugh Hewitt Show, Trump said: “The Pope would rather talk about the fact that it’s OK for Iran to...

The SSPX, the German bishops, and the parable of the two sons by Phil Lawler (From May 5, 2026) 34,085

This summer Pope Leo will face two serious challenges to his authority: one from the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX), which has announced plans to consecrate new bishops without a papal mandate; the other from the German bishops’ conference, which is introducing a ritual for the blessing of...

Why now? The Vatican’s odd ‘clarification’ of Marian piety by Phil Lawler (From Nov 5, 2025) 19,114

So now we see the price that the Catholic Church must pay for the years of confusion over matters of doctrine during the reign of Pope Francis. When the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith (DDF) publishes a statement, designed to clarify the proper language to use in praise of the Virgin Mary,...

Another scandal our bishops have failed to address by Phil Lawler (From Jul 15, 2026) 18,832

Today’s CWN briefs brings the report that the Catholic Theological Society of America (CTSA) has presented its top annual honor, the John Courtney Murray Award, to Bryan Massingale, who describes himself as “both a black theologian and a publicly gay/queer/same-gender loving...

Florida’s upside-down dispute over religious freedom by Phil Lawler (From Aug 6, 2026) 15,131

In the state of Florida, a Catholic lawmaker says that the Catholic bishops are violating a state law that protects religious freedom. The bishop’s defenders fire back, charging that the government official himself is offending against religious freedom, by interfering in church affairs. One...

Why I am not (quite, yet) a Traditionalist: Part I by Phil Lawler (From Dec 5, 2025) 14,199

Imagine that you are a young bachelor, having lunch with an old friend who has just married. Wreathed in smiles, radiating joy, he asks you: “Isn’t my wife the most beautiful woman in the world? Isn’t she just perfect?” She is a very attractive woman; that much is beyond...

My one-step proposal for Vatican reform (Part I) by Phil Lawler (From Jun 11, 2026) 14,129

For 30 years or more, in nearly everything I have written, I have sought to drive home a few key themes: The Catholic Church is in the midst of a serious crisis; That crisis is not merely a matter of sexual abuse, or declining Mass attendance, or doctrinal dissent, or financial collapse,...

Three cardinals don’t speak for the Church by Phil Lawler (From Jan 20, 2026) 13,652

When three American cardinals issued a statement on American foreign policy earlier this week, their comments naturally commanded public attention. Because the prelates stated at the outset that “events in Venezuela, Ukraine and Greenland have raised basic questions about the use of...

An American PR executive in the Vatican’s court by Phil Lawler (From Jun 2, 2026) 13,268

Although I didn’t expect to see an American Pontiff in my lifetime, Leo XIV has settled in at the apostolic palace, and the initial surprise is wearing off. Now brace yourself for another shock. In November an American will be taking control of the stodgy Vatican communications...

An incoherent USCCB intervention on birthright citizenship by Phil Lawler (From Feb 27, 2026) 12,918

In the amicus brief urging the US Supreme Court to restore the “birthright citizenship” policy that was ended by a Trump executive order, the US Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) argues that the key consideration is “whether the law will protect the human dignity of all...