hangin' in there after 2 strikes

By Diogenes (articles ) | Aug 23, 2010

Father Joe Pat Breen has apologized for telling the world that the Church “made a mistake on birth control” and arguing that Catholics are not obligated to obey the Pope, the Nashville diocese tells us. In making that announcement, the diocese also lets it slip that Father Breen is a second-time offender.

Today it’s Bishop David Choby requiring the wayward priest to apologize. The diocese tells us: 

In addition, he has agreed to no longer voice his private concerns publically or in the media as required by a document presented to him by Bishop Edward Kmiec in 1993. 
So back in 1993 he was spouting his own “private concerns” until his bishop blew the whistle, whereupon he agreed to stop. But obviously he didn’t stop, as his recent notoriety demonstrates.

“The Church expects him to work in unity with its authentic teaching as handed down through the pope and the bishops,” Bishop Choby now says. Is that really what a reasonable person would expect? Given his track record, it seems far more likely that Father Breen will encourage dissent from Church teachings; the only question is how vigorously he will dare to express that encouragement.

Bishop Choby’s affirmation of Church teaching is good, strong, and welcome:

It is simply wrong to state, as Father Breen has repeatedly, that one’s conscience frees an individual from the truth revealed and instilled in Church teaching. A deep understanding of Church teaching is, in fact essential to a fully formed conscience, and helps guide an individual in making the distinction between one’s opinions and a decision based soundly on the foundation of a rightly formed conscience. One who chooses to act contrary to Church teaching acts outside of the revealed truth of God’s will.

Nevertheless the fact remains that Father Breen, who has at least twice crossed the line into open dissent, remains a pastor. He expects to be pastor of St. Edward’s church until his scheduled retirement at the end of 2011. And what he “expects” of the diocese is much more likely to be fulfilled than what the Church “expects” of him. 

Any American priest who is credibly accused of abusing a child is immediately suspended from ministry, under the terms of the US bishops’ policies: one strike and you’re out. Father Breen has now been accused twice of what one might call doctrinal abuse, and the evidence to support the charges is voluminous. Still he remains on the job: not just as a priest but as a pastor of souls. Our bishops have learned to take the welfare of children seriously, and for that, thank God. Now if they will just take doctrine seriously, too…

Bishop Choby gave Father Breen one more chance, one more time. “In recognition of his many years of good work among the people of his parish, I want to give Father Breen every opportunity to correct the errors in his teaching, and gracefully enter retirement,” he said. The “many years of good work” could be called into question, but that’s not the way we operate, now is it? One recalls another prelate’s statement of support for a priest who had encountered a bit of trouble:

"Yours has been an effective ministry, sadly marred by illness." 

Sound Off! CatholicCulture.org supporters weigh in.

All comments are moderated. To lighten our editing burden, only current donors are allowed to Sound Off. If you are a donor, log in to see the comment form; otherwise please support our work, and Sound Off!

Show 4 Comments? (Hidden)Hide Comments
  • Posted by: Hal - Aug. 25, 2010 10:36 AM ET USA

    Unfortunately, The Tennessean has used this opportunity to print an endless series of editorial and Letters to the Editor from every dissident Catholic in the diocese, it seems. Some credit to Bishop Choby for finally finding his spine, but where has he been these past years in tolerating this BS which has been pretty much open and notorious?

  • Posted by: - Aug. 24, 2010 5:43 PM ET USA

    Shouldn't a priest's "private concerns" be that of the Church's teachings?

  • Posted by: - Aug. 24, 2010 10:48 AM ET USA

    Father Joe Pat Breen has his own peanut gallery of fans who espouse the same rather heterodox views as himself and are supportive of the good apostate in his many years of injuring his flock during his tenure as pastor. It doesn't therefore surprise me that His Excellency would prefer to have Father Joe Pat go gently into that good night rather than stir up the murky waters of the swamp.

  • Posted by: - Aug. 23, 2010 11:25 PM ET USA

    Could you imagine this end of life voice to one of his failed penitents?: "Yours has been an effective penance, sadly marred by damnation."