Your gift counts double until 5/31: $24,077 to go in our Easter Campaign. Please help now!

Catholic World News News Feature

Cover letter accompanying Vatican instruction warns against homosexual seminary teachers (88 links, updated Fri.) December 02, 2005

  • Letter advises against gay seminary teachers (Washington Post)
  • In letter, Vatican expands gay controls (New York Times)
  • Rainbow Sash Movement reacts to instruction (Rainbow Sash Movement)
  • Homosexual priests, others express anger at Vatican instruction (Catholics Affirming Homosexual Leadership)
  • More quotes from priests critical of instruction (Gay City News)
  • A gay Catholic's response to the Vatican (Gay City News)
  • Reaction from Oakland diocesan spokesman (Oakland Tribune)
  • The 7 links above were posted on Friday, Dec. 2
  • Cardinal Murphy-O'Connor issues statement on document, says, 'The Instruction is not saying than men of homosexual orientation are not welcome in the priesthood' (Diocese of Westminster)
  • Cardinal McCarrick issues statement on new document (Archdiocese of Washington)
  • Statement of South Carolina bishop (Charleston Post Courier)
  • Conference of Major Superiors of Men issues statement (CMSM; PDF)
  • Canadian bishop says document leaves room for cultural interpretation (The Globe and Mail)
  • Detroit seminary officials hail Vatican gay p (Detroit News)
  • US leaders hint at flexibility on gay clergy (AP)
  • Lincoln diocese already in compliance with statement, leaders say (Lincoln Journal-Star)
  • Vatican paper on gays reveals split (Washington Times)
  • Vatican bars all gays as priests (Washington Times)
  • Editorial: Is the Pope unchristian? (Boston Phoenix)
  • Editorial: Vatican avoids prejudice on gay issue (Toronto Star)
  • Editorial: Vatican: Gays need not apply (Berkshire Eagle)
  • Editorial: Something queer afoot in the Vatican (Georgetown Voice)
  • Father Andrew Greeley: Vatican shows some sensitivity to homosexuals (Arizona Daily Star)
  • Barbara Kralis: Barbara Kralis: Does the U.S. bishops' president support the ordination of homosexual men to priesthood? (Renew America)
  • Op-ed: How to ignore the Vatican's ruling on gay priest: the 'interpretive dance' of some prelates (The New Republic)
  • Op-ed: Catholicism holds onto the past (Northern Star)
  • Op-ed: Vatican wants 'ex-gay' priests (Gay.com)
  • Op-ed: Catholic Church's policy on gays isn't enlightened (USA Today)
  • The 20 links above were posted on Thursday, Dec. 1
  • Sharp disagreement between Bishop D'Arcy on the one hand and Cardinal McCarrick, Bishop Skylstad, and Bishop Clark on the other over interpretation of document (Washington Post)
  • Transcript of interview with Bishop Skylstad (Washington Post)
  • Bishop D'Arcy believes gays shouldn't be ordained (Fort Wayne Journal Gazette)
  • Father Fessio, another Jesuit debate document; Jesuit Gregorian University liturgy professor Father Keith Pecklers criticizes document (PBS)
  • Texas bishop says document has nothing to do with the scandal; openly homosexual Dominican condemns it (Austin American-Statesman)
  • Delaware bishop supports stand issued by Pope on gays (Wilmington News-Journal)
  • Reaction from Dallas bishop, seminary rector (Dallas Morning News)
  • Vatican defends policy on gay priests (AP)
  • Vatican directive on gays debated (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)
  • Utah diocesan officials unavailable for comment (Salt Lake Tribune)
  • Phoenix bishop welcomes ban on gay priests (Arizona Republic)
  • Vermont bishop issues lengthy public statement (Rutland Herald)
  • Seminary ban angers gay leaders (Hartford Courant)
  • More comments from Bishops Cupich, Kicanas, Skylstad (USA Today)
  • Sydney auxiliary bishop says document offers flexibility in dealing with candidates with 'strong homosexual tendencies' (ABC Australia)
  • Tucson bishop, Courage's Father Harvey praise document; bishop says no easy answer to question of whether document bans all gay seminarians (Arizona Daily Star)
  • Praise for document from Tennessee diocesan chancellor (WVLT-TV)
  • Vatican officially releases document banning gay priests (New York Times)
  • Op-ed: Vatican statement confuses gay policy (Wisconsin State Journal)
  • Op-ed: A Church confused over sexual issues (Boston Globe)
  • Bishop Skylstad calls Vatican directive on homosexuality 'timely' (USCCB)
  • Bishop Skylstad's earlier comments on the document (Inland Register, Oct. 20)
  • Phoenix priest resigns pastorate over Vatican directive on homosexuality; being a priest, he says, 'like a Jew wearing a Nazi uniform' (Arizona Republic)
  • Text of priest's resignation letter to parish (November 27 parish bulletin, Queen of Peace, Mesa, AZ)
  • Vatican fuels gay clergy debate; Father Reese: 'Although there is still a great deal of homophobia in the United States, it pales by comparison with Africa and Latin America" (BBC)
  • Debate over gay clergy is testing many faiths (Boston Globe)
  • GLAAD calls on media to scrutinize Vatican document (GLAAD)
  • Nationwide alert issued for Catholics to speak out against Vatican decision banning gays (Human Rigts Campaign)
  • Dr. Gerard J. M. van den Aardweg: Homopriests, Humanae Vitae, and masculinity ( (Kath.net)
  • Op-ed on instruction: Vatican flight from reality (The Australian)
  • Op-ed: The Vatican's new directives (Scripps Howard)
  • Archbishop says Church in Philippines will obey Vatican directive banning entrance of homosexuals into seminary; another archbishop says womanizing priests are just as bad and defends bishop accused of womanizing (Manila Standard Today)
  • Gay ex-priest says Vatican edict will force others away, describes Cardinal McCarrick's reaction to his 'coming out' (Newark Star-Ledger)
  • US Catholics are divided over new directive on gays (New York Times)
  • Father Timothy Radcliffe: Can gays be priests? (The Tablet)
  • Editorial: Vatican edict on gays, priests (Denver Post)
  • Op-ed: Vatican gives another example of bigotry against gay people (Ball State Daily News)
  • Op-ed: The Prada papacy (Daily Illini)
  • Vatican issues a qualified ban on gays in priesthood; spokesman for Archdiocese of Los Angeles says instruction will have little, if any, effect there, fears document will be taken out of context; document blasted by Sister Gramick (Los Angeles Times)
  • Reaction to upcoming document from Father Stephen Meriwether, chancellor of Archdiocese of San Francisco and pastor of largely homosexual parish; chancellor says homosexuals are attracted to priesthood because of their natural inclination to the helping professions, adds Church hearkens back to monarchism, feudalism; fears over crackdown when new archbishop is appointed (San Francisco Bay Guardian)
  • Reaction from Fathers Neuhaus, Curran; George Weigel, Garry Wills (New York Sun)
  • Father Reese: 'A lot of the ones who abused boys were in fact heterosexual'; reaction from Catholics United for the Faith, New Ways Ministry (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)
  • Some priests blast document; Catholics Affirming Homosexual Leadership revealed as group founded by seven priests, mostly from Chicago (Washington Post)
  • Document criticized by priests, deacon candidates, others (Catholics Affirming Homosexual Leadership)
  • In strong terms, Rome is to ban gay priests; reaction from Father Fessio, others (New York Times)
  • Vatican document bars ordination of most gays, criticized by gay activist group; psychologist who evaluated prospective seminarians says if followed it could have enormous effect ( (AP)
  • Reaction from Kissling, Human Rights Campaign (Reuters)
  • Reaction from Emmitsburg seminary rector, Syracuse homosexual priest (CNN)
  • Survivor: Vatican profiles self-described Augustinian community that is left Church over Catholic teaching on homosexuality (The Advocate)
  • Op-ed on document (San Francisco Bay Guardian)
  • Despite bishop's ban, Jesuits to host New Ways Ministry forum on homosexuality (Newsday)
  • Archbishop O'Brien on seminary visitations: 'We don't want our people to think, as our culture is now saying, there's really no difference whether one is gay or straight, is homosexual or heterosexual...' (PBS)
  • Priests found new group 'to affirm the value of our gay/lesbian clergy and religious' (Catholics Affirming Homosexual Leadership)
  • Priests speak out against Vatican's anti-gay policies (Washington Blade)
  • Views vary on Rochester bishop's column about gay priests (Finger Lakes Times)
  • Protestant denomination issues report on 'Vatican scapegoating of gay priests' (The Empty Closet)
  • Rochester bishop vows support for gay priests (Elmira Star-Gazette)
  • Bishop Clark on seminary visitation, homosexual priests; 'we deeply value your ministry' (Rochester Catholic Courier)
  • Details of new Vatican rules on gay priests disclosed; comments from Phil Lawler (New York Times)
  • Vatican to define its policy on gay seminarians; criticism from head of Viatorian religious order (Los Angeles Times)
  • Gay priests struggle with Vatican's rules (AP)
  • Catholic World News Email Newsletter
    Donate to Support this Site: Your contribution will be put to good work.
    Tour the CatholicCulture.org Site
    Shop Amazon to Raise Money for Catholic Culture

    Recent Catholic Commentary

    The Ideal of Pope Francis: the Servant Church 6 hours ago
    The sad decline of self-government 22 hours ago
    That impromptu exorcism again May 22
    The Mystery of the Spirit May 21
    Against a Facile Assurance of Salvation, the Need for Mystery May 21

    Top Catholic News

    Most Important Stories of the Last 30 Days
    Pope strongly supports call for reform in religious life CWN - May 8