Wrecking the car or running the shop?
By Leila Marie Lawler (articles ) | Jun 23, 2003
I've been thinking aboutMark Shea's thoughts on why the Pope doesn't give us a quick fix here in the US. He says that we are like the teenager that wrecked the car and wants daddy to write the check.
I have no idea what's behind the Pope's way of dealing with us, or what he could do to make things better -- even if he relieved us of some bishops (and I do mean relieved), who would he put in their place? Mark is right about that -- we have the bishops we deserve, it seems.
His analogy needs tweaking, though, and maybe being more precise can help us find the solutions. Mark's analogy of the boy wrecking the car presupposes some normality in the family, a stable basis from which a kid can rebel.
Looking at our Church, I have the feeling there are two better analogies:
On the one hand we're like the family in which the adolescents come in every mealtime and trash the table. We have no family life -- every moment is spent cleaning up the mess and yelling about what's wrong.
On the other hand, and with a great sense of paradox, I suggest we're like the family where everything seems just fine -- no one is wrecking cars or screaming, but every mealtime is spent in front of the TV or taken on the run. There's no conflict because there's no contact.
This second model what I think of whenever some well meaning friend tells me that everything is fine in their parish. In this family, the parents are blissfully unaware that the kids are being given bananas to put condoms on in grade school, and the kids have no idea that the parents are unaware.
A normal family has times of doing things together and just being together, enjoying each other's company -- especially at dinner -- without necessarily examining the fact that they are doing so. A real family has an occasional trouble spot but the bonds of love keep things together. Our church here in America doesn't have this kind of family life -- for that matter, our families don't either.
I think Mark is on the right track when he suggests that the problem lies within our culture. And I'm all for confronting our culture, however painful that will be.
But we need holy men to lead us.
To switch analogies, can the sheep survive without a shepherd? I can think of lots of ways the laity can take responsibility for our part in forming the culture. But without a leader, without a shepherd, without a father -- how can our little family survive?
An appeal from our founder, Dr. Jeffrey Mirus:
Dear reader: If you found the information on this page helpful in your pursuit of a better Catholic life, please support our work with a donation. Your donation will help us reach seven million Truth-seeking readers worldwide this year. Thank you!
All comments are moderated. To lighten our editing burden, only current donors are allowed to Sound Off. If you are a donor, log in to see the comment form; otherwise please support our work, and Sound Off!
Posted by: John J Plick -
Jun. 24, 2003 7:40 PM ET USA
There is nothing, absolutely NOTHING which justifies the central authority in Rome ignoring our profound crises and leaving us at the mercy of Bishops who have run amuck.NO child, with the exception of Our Blessed Lord and His most holy Mother, that were ever closely worthy of the profound love of a God-given mother and father. If the thought is even crossing their mind (in Rome) that they are going to "get even" with our independent society in America by ignoring sinful Bishops; How dare they!
Posted by: -
Jun. 23, 2003 11:02 PM ET USA
Many a Catholic "sheep" has had to survive on his own, because his false shepherd was another Judas.
Posted by: -
Jun. 23, 2003 11:32 AM ET USA
Families should definitely be the 1st educators of their children's spiritual & social value system and from their nuturing chosen or selected as neutral & reponsible adults who can lead the Catholic Church. It seems that we now have more laity running our Churches thru Ministries and some, are not the best leaders, favoritism is used and there are many cultures who are overlooked because of prejudice. The Shepherd Priests are overwhelmed and the only way you approach one is in Confessions.