Click here to advertise on CatholicCulture.org

Not Just Teaching, but Change

By Dr. Jeff Mirus (bio - articles - email) | May 24, 2011

There was a time—and it has extended through most of my adult life—when deeply committed Catholics could cling only to those aspects of the Church which are divinely guaranteed. If Catholic publications strayed into dissidence, at least we could reassure ourselves that the Magisterium did not agree with them. If a local priest preached heresy, at least we could find a Church document which contradicted him. If Catholic education broke down all around us, at least we could found our own schools rooted in sacred Tradition.

But during this period, our lament was always that of Psalm 13: “How long, O Lord?”

During the extended pontificate of John Paul II, we witnessed a protracted intellectual battle over the meaning of the Second Vatican Council and even over the nature of the Catholic Faith itself. Perhaps the greatest victory of this campaign was the promulgation of the Catechism of the Catholic Church, which immediately gave the lie to so much preaching, so much religious education, and so many Catholic textbooks. But although the battle for Catholic institutions was waged intellectually (one thinks, for example, of John Paul’s prescription for Catholic universities in Ex Corde Ecclesiae), we saw very little effort to actually take disciplinary control over wayward dioceses, Catholic agencies or Catholic schools.

The Vatican’s hands-off response to the widespread loss of an authentic Catholic identity set the pattern for most bishops. Although the episcopacy improved through the appointments of John Paul II, few bishops did more than teach. Discipline was rare; public confrontation rarer still. But roughly four to five years into the pontificate of Benedict XVI, this finally started to change. More and more bishops developed plans to rebuild their dioceses from within, to challenge the universities within their jurisdiction, and to publicly confront wayward politicians. Recently some bishops have begun even to remove irresponsible priests from ministry (in the United States, for example, this has been done by Bishop Robert Finn and Cardinal Francis George). Such shifts strongly suggest that Rome has been sending a more aggressive message for some time.

And now, in the sixth year of Pope Benedict’s pontificate, the Pope himself has finally begun to set an example by removing at least some notoriously bad bishops from office, which he has done three times in the past year (see The surprising outcome of Bishop Lahey’s trial). It is true that other initiatives were already in progress, such as the Apostolic Visitation of American women religious and the Visitation of the Diocese of Toowoomba, Australia, but an investigation is not always a harbinger of punishment. So the actual removal of several bishops from office in a short time is a sea change.

They say a rising tide lifts all boats, and so we are gratified (but, thankfully, no longer totally shocked) to see the Vatican also begin to put pressure on Catholic social agencies. The keynote speaker for the assembly of Caritas International has just been vetoed, a fact rendered even more significant in that he was a very prominent Dominican priest. Moreover, the Vatican Secretary of State Cardinal Bertone has now rather thoroughly lectured Caritas International on what it means for a social agency to have a Catholic identity. The significance of this escalation of what is at last a pragmatic disciplinary battle cannot be overestimated.

Some would argue that the horrors of the sex abuse scandal have played a major role in bringing churchmen to their senses. Absent the invigorating pontificate of John Paul II and the steady assurance of Benedict XVI, that scandal could just as easily have caused things to spiral further out of control, but it is in the very nature of Divine Providence to use the very timing of earthly events to bring good out of evil. I have no wish to minimize the importance of the frightful mirror that has been held up before the ecclesiastical establishment over the past ten years.

Regardless of the exact combination of causes, which God alone knows, the vital point is that we can point to more than just Catholic teaching as an indicator of the importance of Catholic identity. We can point to specific contemporary disciplinary cases. We can look at each other and nod and say that at last the hierarchy is beginning to “get it”. It is very clear that the current Pope is slowly learning how to choose disciplinary battles he can win, and encouraging his bishops to do the same.

We must of course remember what every good parent already knows, that there is a great deal of the art of the possible in discipline. Therefore, we have no warrant to expect a landslide, or even a controlled torrent of discipline, at least not yet. But being actually able to point to any track record at all of internal discipline is a huge gain and a significant comfort. It seems to me certain that it is also a hopeful foreshadowing of real and concrete changes yet to come.

An appeal from our founder, Dr. Jeffrey Mirus:

Dear reader: If you found the information on this page helpful in your pursuit of a better Catholic life, please support our work with a donation. Your donation will help us reach seven million Truth-seeking readers worldwide this year. Thank you!

Progress toward our July expenses ($15,492 to go):
$35,000.00 $19,508.29
44% 56%
Sound Off! CatholicCulture.org supporters weigh in.

All comments are moderated. To lighten our editing burden, only current donors are allowed to Sound Off. If you are a donor, log in to see the comment form; otherwise please support our work, and Sound Off!

Show 9 Comments? (Hidden)Hide Comments
  • Posted by: impossible - May. 28, 2011 11:41 PM ET USA

    The signs are hopeful, and that's one of the reasons our nightly Rosary prayer includes the intentions of the Holy Father and asking God to grant him length of days in good health.

  • Posted by: geraldodoire7287 - May. 28, 2011 6:28 PM ET USA

    Hopefully we shall see a renaissance of the Church on all fronts i.e moral, liturgical and doctrinal. This is the project which is dear to the heart of our present Holy Father, Pope Benedict XV1. It is a work in progress which will possibly not be completed within the present pontificate. But it is underway and will help to remove confusion and restore clarity in relation to the mission, truth and beauty of the Catholic faith.

  • Posted by: Steve214 - May. 25, 2011 5:34 AM ET USA

    Yes, the difference now is that there is regularly good news. The problem is far from solved, but we are seeing the turn around. A good article about good news!

  • Posted by: koinonia - May. 24, 2011 9:05 PM ET USA

    I believe there are a variety of factors in the dramatic influence of Pope Benedict. Despite evidence that Card. Ratzinger had already experienced something of an epiphany before assuming office as Pope, I believe the graces of the office and the direct inspiration of the Holy Spirit is undeniable in the profound "shift" that has occurred. Furthermore, at his advanced age, it is almost certain that he has had a sense of urgency in dealing quickly and decisively with the more pressing concerns.

  • Posted by: raynearhood3144 - May. 24, 2011 8:26 PM ET USA

    Unfortunately, Cardinal George has failed to do the right thing. Fr. Pfleger has won the battle again. Perhaps, its time for the Cardinal to consider retirement for the good of the Church.

  • Posted by: AgnesDay - May. 24, 2011 7:43 PM ET USA

    That praise song, "I can only imagine" makes me think of what judgment day will be like when all this comes out in the wash. How long, indeed!

  • Posted by: Justin8110 - May. 24, 2011 4:26 PM ET USA

    I agree. Many in the highest levels of the Church are starting to, as you say, "get it" and it is a welcome relief. Just how long it will take is beyond our ability to know but it is happening.

  • Posted by: 30 year priest - May. 24, 2011 1:35 PM ET USA

    I beg to differ regarding Cardinal George. He has already restored Fr. Pfleger--a priest who consistently ignores liturgical law and who invites pro-choice non Catholics to preach--to St. Sabina, where he has served for 6 years as parochial vicar and 30 years as adminostrator and pastor, while at the same time often dealing heavy-handedly with good, comptetent, orthodox priests who have somehow irritated handfuls of loudly vocal Catholics who belong to "the-Church-of-what's-happening-now."

  • Posted by: Cornelius - May. 24, 2011 1:03 PM ET USA

    An argument against more active disciplinary measures in the past has been the possibility of fomenting schism. But I say "let the schism come" if it must. With schism comes clarity: the wolves can no longer wear sheepskins and the faithful come to know them for who they are.

Subscribe for free
Click here to advertise on CatholicCulture.org

Recent Catholic Commentary

Renewal with God before Us: Christ Determines All 16 hours ago
Sons of Dominic Prepare for Family Synod July 29
Dominican theologians assess proposals for divorced and remarried July 29
The ‘Pope Francis effect’—changing the way the world sees the papacy July 29
Renewal with God Behind Us: Man Determines All July 28

Top Catholic News

Most Important Stories of the Last 30 Days
New management, new changes coming for reformed Vatican bank CWN - July 8
Sweeping reforms to Vatican's media, financial operations CWN - July 9
‘Even Genghis Khan didn’t do this’: Mosul emptied of Christians CWN - July 21